Picture two rooms. One holds a bed, a chair, a lamp and a shelf of ten books. The other holds all that and three hundred more things: gadgets, clothes, boxes, cables. The second room looks richer. Each room also asks something of the person who lives in it.
Own it→Store it→Find it→Keep it→Decide about it
Every thing a person owns asks something back. It has to be stored, found, cleaned, charged, updated, or decided about. An app asks for a tap. A subscription asks for a decision each month. A shelf of clutter asks to be looked at every time you pass. Each ask is a small switch, the kind lesson 1 counted.
Phone one
++
Phone twofor games
A person buys a second phone, just for games. What has it added, apart from the games?
Nothing. A phone just sits there until you pick it up.
Not yet. It needs charging, and it updates and lights up on its own, and each of those is an ask for the beam. Even a thing that sits there has to be stored and found.
Asks: charging, updates, lights, a second thing to find and decide about.
Right. Every owned thing comes with its upkeep. The games were the point; the asks come along whether they were wanted or not.
Only the cost of buying it.
Not yet. The price is paid once. The asks are paid every day the thing is owned, which is why this lesson counts them apart from the price.
10 of 40
10 of 40 apps kept
A person has 40 apps, and each lights up once a day. They delete 30 of them. By lesson 1's count, how many switches a day have they bought back?
switches
One light a day from each app is one switch a day from each app.
Right. Thirty lights a day that will not come. Each was a switch; the person kept ten and bought back thirty, every day, for nothing.
Less, forcedno choice
vsvs
Less, chosena decision
There is an old word for having little and keeping it bare: austere. It comes from a Greek word for a taste that dries the tongue, and for centuries it meant harsh or joyless. But the word hides two different situations. Less because you cannot have more, and less because you chose it.
Fewer things
↓→
Fewer asks
↓→
Attention kept
So an austere room by choice is not a punishment. It is a decision about where attention goes. A person who keeps fewer things gives something up and gets something back: the asks those things would have made every day. Fewer things in the room means fewer asks in the day.
Each card is a person with little. Was the little forced, or chosen?
One card at a time. Tap the pile it belongs to.
Card 1 of 5
A family that cannot afford a second coat
A hiker who carries one pan because a second would weigh on her back
A student who deletes six apps to keep one, because each one lit up
A town with no shop for twenty miles
A monk who keeps one robe by the rule of his order
A family that cannot afford a second coat → Forced
Not yet. Forced. There was no choice to make; the little is set by what the family has.
A hiker who carries one pan because a second would weigh on her back → Chosen
Not yet. Chosen. She could buy a second pan. She counted its asks, here the weight on her back, and said no.
A student who deletes six apps to keep one, because each one lit up → Chosen
Not yet. Chosen. The apps were free and already there. The student counted the asks and bought them back.
A town with no shop for twenty miles → Forced
Not yet. Forced. Nobody in the town decided to have less; the distance decided for them.
A monk who keeps one robe by the rule of his order → Chosen
Not yet. Chosen. Joining the order was the decision, and the one robe comes with it. He could have more and the rule he chose says no.
2Forced
vsvs
3Chosen
Right. Two forced, three chosen. The thing in the room can look the same: one pan, one coat, one app. What differs is whether the person could have had more and said no.
Set how many things a person keeps against how much free attention they have in a day, and watch what is left for the things themselves. Made up to show the shape.
Asks from things20 a day, made up
Attention free40 a day, made up
Things kept: Few · Attention free: Little
A few things ask 20 times a day; 40 are free. 20 left for the day.
Asks from things20 a day, made up
Attention free80 a day, made up
Things kept: Few · Attention free: Some
A few things ask 20 times a day; 80 are free. 60 left for the day.
Asks from things20 a day, made up
Attention free160 a day, made up
Things kept: Few · Attention free: Lots
A few things ask 20 times a day; 160 are free. 140 left for the day.
Asks from things60 a day, made up
Attention free40 a day, made up
Things kept: Many · Attention free: Little
Many things ask 60 times a day; only 40 are free. 20 asks go unanswered, and the person feels behind.
Asks from things60 a day, made up
Attention free80 a day, made up
Things kept: Many · Attention free: Some
Many things ask 60 times a day; 80 are free. 20 left for the day.
Asks from things60 a day, made up
Attention free160 a day, made up
Things kept: Many · Attention free: Lots
Many things ask 60 times a day; 160 are free. 100 left for the day.
Asks from things120 a day, made up
Attention free40 a day, made up
Things kept: Hundreds · Attention free: Little
Hundreds of things ask 120 times a day; only 40 are free. 80 asks go unanswered, and the person feels behind.
Asks from things120 a day, made up
Attention free80 a day, made up
Things kept: Hundreds · Attention free: Some
Hundreds of things ask 120 times a day; only 80 are free. 40 asks go unanswered, and the person feels behind.
Asks from things120 a day, made up
Attention free160 a day, made up
Things kept: Hundreds · Attention free: Lots
Hundreds of things ask 120 times a day; 160 are free. 40 left for the day.
With hundreds of things, which setting of free attention still leaves some over?
Any of them. Things do not use attention.
Not yet. The frames count 120 asks a day for hundreds of things, and two of the three settings fall short of that. Each ask is a switch, and switches are paid for.
None. Hundreds of things always cost more than anyone has.
Not yet. The frames give one setting with 40 to spare. A person with lots of free attention can carry hundreds of things. The point is the price, not that it cannot be paid.
Only lots. With little or some, the things ask for more than there is.
Right. At hundreds, the asks run to 120 a day in the frames, and only the largest free attention, 160, covers them. More things is a bill paid in attention.
Move both controls.
The same room
++
Forced, or chosen?
A tidy, nearly empty flat is photographed for a magazine and called quiet luxury. Using this lesson, why can a nearly empty room be a sign of plenty and not of poverty?
It cannot. An empty room always means the owner has nothing.
Not yet. The sort in this lesson had two kinds of little. One pan on a hiker's back and one pan in a bare kitchen look alike; whether there was a choice is what differs.
Because the magazine says so.
Not yet. A label is not a reason. The lesson's reason is the owner's choice. The same room, with no choice behind it, is the forced kind of little from the sort.
Because the owner could have filled it and chose not to, and the few things left ask little.
Right. The room shows a decision. A few things, each asking little, leave the owner's attention free for the day.
Lesson complete
Every thing owned asks for attention; less that was chosen buys those asks back.