Climate · Friday, 20 November 2026
Written by AI agents built on Claude, from the sources they cite, and overseen by Zeemish. How it's made
This day: every beat The day in 12 minutes
COP31 reaches its scheduled last day in Antalya with a draft deal that drops every mention of fossil fuels
Signals on this beat
Fossil fuels kept in play High ↑
- The latest COP31 draft drops every mention of fossil fuels.
[1] - China, the US and Russia pledged to boost supplies of refined petroleum products.
[10] - The US Senate bill speeds permits for gas pipelines as well as power lines.
[11]
Data centres pulling on grids Building ↑
- Advocates say data centres in PJM's forecast could add $5 billion to $10 billion to customers' costs.
[12] - New York expects 1,700 megawatts of new data centre demand by 2036.
[13] - Meta is reconsidering its 2030 net zero goal.
[14]
Customers paying for power choices Building ↑
- Orders to keep a Florida coal plant open have cost customers $25.6 million.
[15] - PJM's market monitor says data centres have already added $29.4 billion to capacity costs.
[12] - Petrol in Sanaa, Yemen, rose 20% in a few weeks.
[16]
El Nino swinging the weather High ↑
- Indonesia's fires released nearly 200 million tonnes of carbon in a dry El Nino year.
[17] - California's coast faces king tides on record-high seas.
[18] - Rain woke the Atacama Desert into its biggest bloom seen from space.
[19]
The stories
22 on this beat today.
Each story is told in its parts: what happened, the questions that explain it, how it works, who gains and who pays, and the good news. A part appears when the sources give it.
-
01
COP31 reaches its scheduled last day in Antalya with a draft deal that drops every mention of fossil fuels
80
paragraphs left in the draft deal, down from 144
the fossil fuel exit was among the cuts
[3] 35%
of world final energy from electricity by 2035, the goal kept
it does not say the power must be clean
[2] $305bn
a year poorer countries need to adapt, up to 2035
the tripling under talks reaches at least $120 billion
[2] What happened
-
The newest draft deal at COP31, the UN climate summit in Antalya, Turkey, drops every mention of fossil fuels.
[1] -
Fossil fuels are coal, oil and gas, the main cause of the warming.
[2] -
Nearly 200 countries must all agree before any text is adopted.
[2] -
The summit was scheduled to end on Friday 20 November, though the talks often run into the weekend.
[3] -
The second draft swapped the promise to move away from fossil fuels for a weaker line.
[1] -
It now promises "an irreversible global transition towards low greenhouse gas emissions and climate resilience".
[1] -
The text shrank from 144 paragraphs on 16 November to 80 paragraphs on 19 November.
[3] -
It also dropped net zero dates.
[3] It dropped a firm $120 billion target for money to help poorer countries adapt.[3] -
A goal to meet 35% of the world's final energy use with electricity by 2035 stays in.
[2] -
Today the share is around 20%.
[2] The draft does not say the extra electricity must come from clean sources.[2] -
So electricity made from coal would count toward the goal too.
[4] -
The draft keeps a call to scale up machines that catch carbon dioxide.
[3] -
An earlier draft set at least 500 million tonnes a year by 2035.
[5] Nothing near that scale has ever been built.[5] -
Bowen said the text offers "the most ambitious results that consensus will allow".
[1] -
Kurum said the fossil fuel words were agreed at earlier summits: "I don't think there's any backsliding".
[1] -
Panama wants a cap on oil production and steps to eliminate methane, a potent warming gas.
[2]
Who is involved
Chris Bowen, Australia's climate minister, leads the talks with Turkey's Murat Kurum, the summit's president.
[1] Panama wrote to both presidents that it would block any outcome unless all its demands were met.
[1] - Oil burned for fuel
- Coal burned for power
- Gas burned for power and heat
- Chris Bowen Australia's climate and energy minister, who runs the negotiations; says the text is what consensus allows
- Murat Kurum Turkey's minister and president of the summit; says leaving out the words is no backsliding
- Panama a small Central American country; says it will block any deal without a cap on oil output
- Fossil fuel producers refused the old words, campaigners say
- Mohamed Adow head of Power Shift Africa, a think tank; warns of a 'ghost' summit
How it unfolded
At COP28 in Dubai in 2023, countries agreed to transition away from fossil fuels.
[6] At COP30 in Belem, Brazil, last year, that transition was erased from the final deal.
[6] Campaigners blame some fossil fuel producing countries that refused to let the old promise stand.
[1] Four countries, Finland, France, Germany and the Netherlands, have published national plans to leave fossil fuels.
[7] - Friday scheduled close
- Weekend talks often run on
-
2023
Dubai summit agrees to transition away from fossil fuels
[6] - Last year Belem: the exit left out
- Thursday second draft
- Friday onward a text all can accept
-
2025
Belem summit leaves the fossil fuel exit out
[6] -
16 Nov
first draft, 144 paragraphs
[3] -
19 Nov
second draft, 80 paragraphs, no fossil fuels
[3] -
20 Nov
scheduled last day
[3]
Why it matters
Pacific island states rank a fossil fuel exit among their top demands, as seas rise around them.
[8] A separate text on money for poorer countries produced a largely empty document.
[1] It made no progress on the $300 billion a year rich countries pledged poorer ones by 2035.
[1] Think it through
-
1
Why would the hosts cut words so many countries want?
Every country must agree, so one objection is enough to sink the deal.
[2] One country objectsNo consensusNo deal -
2
Do the hosts gain from the softer text?
Critics note that both host countries have big fossil fuel interests.
[8] Turkey's president celebrated an oil discovery as the summit opened.[7] -
3
So who pays if the money stays thin?
Poorer countries need an estimated $305 billion a year to adapt to a hotter world.
[2] The tripling under talks reaches at least $120 billion.[2] $ billion a year
Needed a year305Tripling target120What adapting costs, against what is on the table -
4
Why won't the rich countries pay more?
The EU says it pays its fair share while others do not.
[2] Its delegation head, Darragh O'Brien, says it brought no additional money.[9] -
5
Does a missing word change what countries burn?
Not directly: Germany's Heike Henn says success lies "in doing, in a growing coalition".
[6] Several countries are writing their own exit plans.[6] -
6
What does the Shenzhen summit have to do with it?
On Thursday Xi, Trump and Putin vowed to raise output of refined petroleum products.
[1] An African negotiator, Tlou Ramaru, called it hypocrisy.[1] Antalyafossil fuels cut from textShenzhenmore fuel promised -
7
So who can still change the text before it closes?
Any one country can still refuse, as Panama threatens to.
[2] The hosts planned meetings with each group through the night.[1]
How it works
Diplomats call the summit's main text a cover decision: one political statement framing the whole meeting.
[3] This cover decision needs the consensus of all parties and is usually finalised last.
[3] The presidency says earlier drafts were not meant to reflect consensus.[3] Seen it before
A class choosing one film everyone must agree to often ends up with the one nobody minds.
The truth
-
What is really going on
At COP31, the fossil fuel words were cut while the money for poorer countries stayed thin.
[1] -
Why it works on people
Bowen's line that the text is "the most ambitious results that consensus will allow" makes the cut sound like the only choice, while Panama is still pushing for more.
[1] [2] - Kurum says the Dubai words still stand, so leaving them out is no backsliding.
[1] Oxfam's Jan Kowalzig calls it insufficient for a summit focused on implementation.[2]
Good news
- Four more countries, Spain, Portugal, Denmark and Luxembourg, announced their own fossil fuel exit plans on 17 November.
[6]
What comes next
The text is expected to be revised again before it can be adopted.
[2] Bowen said no one would leave Antalya until there is consensus.[2] -
The newest draft deal at COP31, the UN climate summit in Antalya, Turkey, drops every mention of fossil fuels.
-
02
US Senate passes the permitting bill
What happened
-
The US Senate voted 62 to 33 on Thursday to pass a bill that speeds up permits for energy projects.
[20] -
Without federal permits, developers cannot build on federal land or across state lines.
[11] -
The bill shortens environmental reviews, narrows who can sue and shortens the deadline to do so.
[11] -
It also lets federal regulators approve a power line if a state refuses or does not act within a year.
[21] -
More Democrats voted against it than for it, though Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer backed it.
[20]
Who is involved
- Most Democrats against
- Schumer and over a dozen more for
How it unfolded
- Thursday Senate passes it
- Next the House votes
Why it matters
Wind and solar farms often wait years for power lines to carry their electricity to cities.
[11] Gas pipelines get faster approval too.[11] Think it through
-
1
So does it help clean power or gas more?
Rhodium Group, a research firm, estimates 17 to 249 gigawatts more clean power by 2040.
[20] It sees gas exports rising 8% to 15% more.[20] +17 to 249 GWClean power by 2040+8% to 15%Gas exports -
2
Why are some green groups against it?
The NRDC, the Sierra Club and the Union of Concerned Scientists fear it eases fossil fuel building.
[22] A finished permit could be revoked only in narrow cases, such as fraud.[21] Permit grantedHard to take backA later government is stuck with it -
3
Why rush it through now?
Its backers want it passed before Democrats take control of the US Congress in January.
[21] They bet this chance will not come again.[21] -
4
So who can still stop it?
The House holds it now: likely incoming Democratic committee chair Jared Huffman urges Democrats to vote no.
[20]
How it works
Lawyers call this permitting reform: changing the reviews a project must pass before it can be built.
[11] Permitting reform here trades public scrutiny for speed.
[11] With fewer reviews and lawsuits, power lines and pipelines alike get built sooner.[11] Seen it before
A school that drops a test to save time also loses the chance to catch mistakes.
The truth
- Rhodium's range runs from 5 to 148 million tonnes less greenhouse gas a year by 2040.
[20] So whether the bill cuts much pollution is not yet known.[20]
What comes next
The bill now goes to the US House of Representatives, then to President Trump, who supports it.
[20] -
The US Senate voted 62 to 33 on Thursday to pass a bill that speeds up permits for energy projects.
-
03
Xi, Trump and Putin promise more fuel
What happened
-
The leaders of China, the US and Russia met in Shenzhen, China, on Thursday.
[10] -
Their joint declaration pledged to boost supplies of refined petroleum products to address global energy challenges.
[10] -
The declaration did not mention Russia's war in Ukraine or the US-led war in Iran.
[10] -
The Iran war has cost the world 2.8 billion barrels of oil from the Gulf, the IEA says.
[23]
Who is involved
- Xi Jinping China's president, the host
- Donald Trump US president
- Vladimir Putin Russia's president
Why it matters
The pledge came on the day COP31's draft dropped fossil fuels.
[1] An African negotiator, Tlou Ramaru, called it hypocrisy.[1] Think it through
-
1
Can Russia make more fuel right now?
Ukrainian drones have cut Russian refinery processing by 45% since late October, Reuters reported.
[23] 45%less crude processed at Russian refineries
-
2
Who gains most from the meeting?
Putin gained most, analysts told DW: he stood beside the US and Chinese leaders as an equal.
[10]
How it works
Economists call it supply and demand: more fuel offered, with demand unchanged, pushes the price down.
Here the war has removed 2.8 billion barrels of Gulf oil.
[23] By supply and demand, more fuel from the three would ease prices, if it came.[10] Seen it before
When a shop restocks a sold-out toy, its price stops climbing.
The truth
- DW's report of the declaration gives no amount or date for the extra fuel.
[10]
-
The leaders of China, the US and Russia met in Shenzhen, China, on Thursday.
-
04
Oil edges up as tankers are hit
What happened
-
The price of Brent crude oil rose 0.8% to $92.72 a barrel on Thursday.
[23] -
Iran's navy said two tankers hit naval mines in the Strait of Hormuz and exploded.
[23] Reuters could not verify it.[23] -
The Strait of Hormuz, the Gulf's sea exit, carried about a fifth of the world's oil shipments before the war.
[24] -
The day before, prices fell on rising US oil stocks and forecasts of too much supply.
[23] -
A US crude called Mars fell from a $10 premium over the US benchmark, West Texas Intermediate.
[25] In under a month it sank to a $4 discount.[25]
How it unfolded
Mars traded at a record $17.50 premium in March and April, when the war cut Gulf supply.
[25] - Wednesday prices fall
- Thursday prices rise 0.8%
Why it matters
Cheaper heavy crude helps US refiners, who are already making record profits from the war.
[25] Think it through
-
1
Why is US crude suddenly cheap?
Oil from Canada, Venezuela and the Middle East is surging into the market.
[25] Canada's west-coast pipeline runs at a record 960,000 barrels a day.[25] 960,000barrels a day through Canada's export pipeline
-
2
So who loses from the glut?
Heavy oil producers pay: one says it now has to be "a price taker".
[25]
How it works
Traders call the extra price for one oil over a benchmark a premium, and the shortfall a discount.
[25] Mars is like Gulf crude, so it earned a premium when Gulf oil was cut off.
[25] Now heavy barrels abound, so it sells at a discount.[25] Seen it before
Umbrellas cost more on a rainy day when the shop runs short, and less once a delivery arrives.
The truth
- Iran's claim that two tankers exploded has not been independently confirmed.
[23] A UBS analyst says rising Iranian attacks are tightening the oil market.[23]
-
The price of Brent crude oil rose 0.8% to $92.72 a barrel on Thursday.
-
05
A fight over when climate science lands
What happened
-
Some countries are holding up the next big report of the IPCC, the UN's panel of climate scientists.
[26] -
Russia, India and the Arab Group, which includes Saudi Arabia, want it delayed until 2029.
[26] -
Most countries want it in 2028, in time for the global stocktake at COP33.
[27] -
The global stocktake is how progress toward the Paris climate goal is judged.
[26] -
India and Saudi Arabia are also blocking the IPCC's budget, causing a funding crisis.
[27] -
European diplomats are courting China to break the deadlock.
[27]
Who is involved
- Europe wants 2028
- China being courted
How it unfolded
- 2028 most want the report
- 2029 the delay some want
Why it matters
Without the report, the 2028 stocktake would lack fresh science on how far the world is falling short.
[27] Think it through
-
1
What do the delaying countries say they want?
They say developing countries' scientists need more time: "You have to give adequate time".
[27] -
2
Is the panel really run by rich countries?
Of 664 IPCC authors, 51% come from developing countries, the panel says.
[26] 51%of IPCC authors from developing countries
-
3
So why delay it at all?
Nepal's negotiator Raju Pandit Chhetri called the racism charge "a political line".
[26] He said some countries fear stronger science will push them to cut.[26] -
4
So who can end the stand-off?
The timeline is set by consensus, so a few countries can hold it.
[27] China's choice may decide whether they fold.[27]
How it works
Scientists call this an assessment: a review of everything already published on a question.
[26] The IPCC assessment sums up established research, so a delay holds back the summary governments use for the stocktake.
[26] Seen it before
A school report written after the parents' meeting cannot help that meeting.
The truth
- Campaigner Lidy Nacpil says the panel's pathways are biased against the global south.
[26] Johan Rockstrom, a leading climate scientist, says the evidence has no such bias.[26]
-
Some countries are holding up the next big report of the IPCC, the UN's panel of climate scientists.
-
06
Meta rethinks its 2030 climate goal
What happened
-
Meta, which owns Facebook and Instagram, said it is reconsidering its 2030 deadline for net zero emissions.
[14] -
Net zero means cutting emissions as far as possible and paying to remove the rest.
[14] -
Meta's emissions rose 45% in 2025, to 11.8 million tonnes.
[14] -
Meta says its plans require building the data centres that power artificial intelligence.
[14] -
The IEA, the world's energy watchdog, says data centre emissions will rise 70% by 2030.
[28] -
Data centres could use up to 1,000 terawatt-hours a year by 2030, double today, the IEA says.
[29]
How it unfolded
Meta set the goal in 2020, across its whole value chain, from what it buys to what it builds.
[14] - 2020 net zero by 2030 promised
- Now the date under review
Why it matters
The IEA says US data centres will get about 60% of their power from gas by 2030.
[28] Think it through
-
1
Why does AI mean more gas?
Plans for about 180 gigawatts of new gas plants were linked to US data centres in August.
[28] That is almost all the gas capacity in the EU.[28] 180 GWof new gas plants linked to US data centres
-
2
Is it only Meta?
Anthropic, which makes the Claude AI, reportedly signed a $3.4 billion deal for gas-fired engines in September.
[30] $3.4 billionAnthropic's reported gas power deal
-
3
So who is pulling back from climate pledges?
Google said this year its emissions were still rising.
[14] Walmart said in 2024 it would miss its first target.[14]
How it works
Sustainability managers call it an absolute target: a cap on total emissions, however big the firm grows.
Meta's absolute target assumed steady growth and falling clean energy costs.
[14] AI building grew faster, and its emissions rose 45%.[14] Seen it before
A savings goal set before a big unexpected bill suddenly looks out of reach.
The truth
- Meta's 11.8 million tonnes rests on counting methods that climate advocates distrust.
[14] -
Nobody knows yet
When, or whether, Meta sets a new net zero date.
It says it is re-evaluating its timelines and interim milestones, and has given no new date.
[14]
-
Meta, which owns Facebook and Instagram, said it is reconsidering its 2030 deadline for net zero emissions.
-
07
States ask a grid to delay its power auction
What happened
-
Consumer advocates from 7 US states asked PJM to delay its December power auction.
[12] -
PJM runs the grid for 67 million customers across 13 states.
[12] -
PJM's capacity auction buys power supplies three years ahead of when they are needed.
[12] -
PJM's market monitor says the forecast includes data centres that are cancelled or unlikely to use what was predicted.
[12] -
The monitor warns that could add $5 billion to $10 billion to customers' costs.
[12]
How it unfolded
- 23 November advocates want PJM's answer
- 9 December the auction opens
Why it matters
Households and businesses on PJM's grid pay these costs in their electricity bills.
[12] Think it through
-
1
How much have data centres added so far?
Counting data centre demand has already raised capacity costs by $29.4 billion for all customers, the monitor says.
[12] $29.4 billionadded to capacity costs so far
-
2
Why don't the data centres pay?
PJM's rules effectively stop data centre firms paying for their own power and grid costs.
[12] Data centre forecastAuction buys more powerEveryone's bill rises -
3
So who decides whether the auction moves?
PJM says delay could unsettle the market and raise the risk of power cuts.
[12] It holds the date, and needs a federal regulator's approval to move it.[12]
How it works
Energy economists call this resource adequacy: having enough power plants for the busiest hour.
PJM buys resource adequacy for its forecast, so growing data centre forecasts have pushed up capacity prices for all.
[12] Seen it before
A school that orders desks for pupils who never enrol still pays for every desk.
Why every household pays for power plants a grid books years ahead
Energy economists call it resource adequacy: a grid pays plants years ahead to cover its forecast busiest hour, and every customer pays for them.
The twist
Your power bill is set by a forecast, not only by what anyone uses, so a data centre that is never built can still raise it.
The picture
$29.4bnAdded so far$5bn to $10bnDoubtful data centresPJM's market monitor says counting data centres has already added $29.4bn to capacity costs, and doubtful ones could add $5bn to $10bn more. Step by step
- A grid forecasts its busiest hour years ahead
- It pays power plants to be ready for that hour
- Every customer's bill carries the payment
- If the forecast is too high, customers pay anyway
The same force, elsewhere today
Where this chain is also running, in today's other stories.
-
States ask a grid to delay its power auction
PJM buys plants for a forecast that includes data centres that may never come, and all customers pay.
-
New York faces a power shortfall from 2033
the operator's forecast of new demand decides how much power it must buy years ahead.
-
Keeping a Florida coal plant open costs $25.6m
the US Energy Department cites expected data centre demand to keep a plant its customers must pay for.
-
North America's grid looks safer this winter
26.2 gigawatts more power at peak was added to cover the coldest forecast hour.
Seen it before
Hospitals
beds are kept for the worst flu week, and paid for all year
Fire brigades
engines wait for fires that may not come
Schools
classrooms are built for the pupils a town expects
The catch
Too little power means blackouts on a cold night, so planners lean high, and a wrong forecast shows only years later.
And the whole of it
Every household on a grid pays its share of a forecast made years earlier by planners it never meets. Nobody, the planners included, knows the right number until the coldest night arrives.
The truth
- PJM says its December auction has a price cap to limit how high prices go.
[12] The advocates say the forecast itself is inflated with speculative demand.[12] -
Nobody knows yet
Whether PJM's data centre forecast shrinks before the auction.
PJM was due to publish its final auction numbers on 19 November, which may remove cancelled or delayed data centres.
[12]
What comes next
The auction, for power in 2029 and 2030, is set for 9 to 15 December.
[12] The advocates want a reply by 23 November.[12] -
Consumer advocates from 7 US states asked PJM to delay its December power auction.
-
08
New York faces a power shortfall from 2033
What happened
-
New York's grid operator says the state will be short of power from 2033.
[13] -
The gap starts at about 225 megawatts and grows to more than 1,850 megawatts by 2036.
[13] -
New demand includes 1,700 megawatts from data centres and 1,000 from factories.
[13] -
About 5,400 megawatts of gas power may be unavailable on winter peaks, partly because fuel cannot reach it.
[13]
How it unfolded
- 2033 first shortfall, 225 MW
- 2036 shortfall over 1,850 MW
Why it matters
New York City alone could be short about 400 megawatts in 2032.
[13] Think it through
-
1
Why worry about 2033 now?
Plants take years to plan, permit and build, the operator says: the need is "no longer a distant concern".
[13] -
2
Isn't the old fleet still there?
About 4,600 megawatts of fossil plants will be over 70 years old by 2036.
[13] 4,600 MWof fossil plants over 70 years old by 2036
-
3
So how close to the edge is the grid?
The operator expects emergency steps on about 3.5 days next year, rising to 21 days by 2036.
[13] Days of emergency steps
Next year3.5203621Days the grid will need emergency measures
How it works
Grid planners call it a reliability need: a forecast hour when supply falls short of demand.
[13] New York's reliability need grows as data centres arrive and old plants retire.
[13] The idea, in story 07: Why every household pays for power plants a grid books years ahead →Seen it before
A bus with more riders each year and older seats each year will one day be too full.
The truth
- The gap depends on demand forecasts, which the operator will update before acting.
[13]
What comes next
The operator will seek backup power from the market if the gap remains.
[13] -
New York's grid operator says the state will be short of power from 2033.
-
09
North America's grid looks safer this winter
What happened
-
NERC, the watchdog for North America's power grids, says this winter looks safer than last.
[31] -
Power available at peak grew 26.2 gigawatts, or 2.4%, led by batteries and gas plants.
[31] -
Fewer old plants retiring also helped, NERC said.
[31] -
No region faces a high risk of shortfalls, NERC said.
[31] Parts of the Midwest, Southeast and New England could struggle in extreme weather.[31]
Who is involved
- New England short of gas pipelines
- Midwest and Southeast line limits
Why it matters
NERC says El Nino adds uncertainty to this winter.
[31] El Nino is warm Pacific water shifting east toward South America.[18] Think it through
-
1
Why is winter the hardest season?
Cold snaps push up home heating and power demand together.
[31] Gas plants without long contracts can then lose their fuel.[31] Cold snapHomes burn more gasSome gas plants go short -
2
So where is the weak spot?
New England has few gas pipelines, so its risk stays elevated.
[31]
How it works
Engineers call this a fuel constraint: plants exist, but the fuel cannot reach them in time.
[31] In New England the fuel constraint is the pipelines: on the coldest days homes and plants share too little gas.
[31] The idea, in story 07: Why every household pays for power plants a grid books years ahead →Seen it before
A kitchen with one tap slows down when everyone wants water at once.
The truth
- El Nino can bring a mild winter, NERC says, but ice storms and deep cold can hide within those averages.
[31] -
Nobody knows yet
How hard this El Nino hits the coming winter.
Scientists quoted in California call it possibly the strongest in 1,000 years, yet NERC says El Nino can also bring a mild winter.
[18] [31]
Good news
- North America's grid goes into winter with 26.2 gigawatts more power at its peak than a year ago, led by batteries and gas plants.
-
NERC, the watchdog for North America's power grids, says this winter looks safer than last.
-
10
Keeping a Florida coal plant open costs $25.6m
What happened
-
Federal orders keeping a coal plant in Orlando, Florida, running have cost its customers about $25.6 million.
[15] -
The figure comes from an analysis by the Environmental Defense Fund, an environmental group.
[15] -
The Orlando Utilities Commission planned to shut one of two coal units at its Stanton plant in May.
[15] -
The US Energy Department ordered it kept open in June, then again in September.
[15] -
The six plants under such orders have cost customers about $593 million in all, the group says.
[15]
How it unfolded
The orders use a law for short emergencies, such as storms.
[15] The Trump administration keeps renewing them.[15] - June first order
- September second order, to 30 November
Why it matters
The utility serves more than 288,000 customers in central Florida.
[15] Think it through
-
1
Why does the US Energy Department want it open?
The department cites a shortage of plants and growing data centre demand in Florida.
[15] -
2
Why does it cost so much?
Coal has been the utility's most costly fuel per unit of power in recent years.
[15] Keeping the unit running costs about $6.2 million a month.[15] $6.2 milliona month to keep the unit going
-
3
So who decides if it finally closes?
Earthjustice, a law group, expects another order when this one ends on 30 November.
[15]
How it works
Grid regulators call it a must-run plant: one kept running by order, not because it is cheapest.
Stanton became a must-run plant by federal order, so customers pay for its costly coal.
[15] The idea, in story 07: Why every household pays for power plants a grid books years ahead →Seen it before
Keeping an old car you meant to sell still means paying its repairs.
The truth
-
What is really going on
From Pennsylvania to Florida, US power customers are paying for plants bought on forecasts and federal orders they had no say in.
[12] [15] - The department says the orders likely saved hundreds of lives in winter storms.
[15] Earthjustice says the plant is not needed for reliability.[15]
-
Federal orders keeping a coal plant in Orlando, Florida, running have cost its customers about $25.6 million.
-
11
A UK refinery fined for 489 breaches
What happened
-
The operator of the Stanlow oil refinery in Cheshire, England, has been fined 800,000 pounds.
[32] -
It broke its wastewater limits at least 489 times between 2018 and 2020, the Environment Agency said.
[32] -
The owner, Essar Oil UK, which trades as EET Fuels, pleaded guilty to 12 charges in March.
[32] -
Oil, solids and chemicals including cyanide went into local streams and the Manchester Ship Canal.
[32] -
The court fined it 80,000 pounds for each of 10 offences.
[32]
Who is involved
- EET Fuels Essar's refinery company, pleaded guilty
Why it matters
One spill reached Thornton Brook, which leads to the protected Mersey Estuary.
[32] Think it through
-
1
Has the refinery fixed the problem?
EET Fuels says it has invested more than 24 million pounds to improve.
[32] 24 million poundsspent on fixes, the company says
-
2
So did the breaches stop?
Three later breaches from 2022 and 2023 brought no extra penalty.
[32]
How it works
Regulators call this a permit: the limits a plant must keep to be allowed to run.
[32] Stanlow's permit set wastewater limits, and the agency counted each breach of them.
[32] Seen it before
A library card lets you borrow, until late returns pile up.
The truth
- The agency called it "a repeated failure to comply".
[32] The company calls them "historic incidents".[32]
-
The operator of the Stanlow oil refinery in Cheshire, England, has been fined 800,000 pounds.
-
12
Indonesia's fires near a record
What happened
-
Indonesia's fires released nearly 200 million tonnes of carbon this year, the EU's Copernicus service said on Thursday.
[17] -
That is the third highest since records began in 2003.
[17] The record, in 2015, was nearly 400 million tonnes.[17] -
Copernicus is the EU's climate monitoring service.
[17] -
About 8.9 million hectares may have burned, 4.7% of the country.
[17]
How it unfolded
A very dry El Nino year drove the fires, with clearing of land.
[17] Why it matters
The fires equal more than a fifth of Indonesia's yearly carbon from energy and industry.
[17] Think it through
-
1
Why does Indonesia burn so hard?
Draining wet peat land for palm oil and pulpwood makes it easier to burn.
[17] Drained peatDry fuel underfootBig fires -
2
Do all counts agree?
Nusantara Atlas, a monitoring platform with a more cautious method, put January to October at 2.9 million hectares.
[17] 8.9 million haCopernicus2.9 million haNusantara Atlas
How it works
Climate scientists call this a compound event: drought and heat together make fires worse.
In Indonesia the compound event was El Nino's drought on top of warmer temperatures.
[17] Seen it before
A dry match lights easily; a dry match in the wind lights faster.
The truth
- The two burned-area counts differ, partly because Nusantara Atlas uses a more conservative method.
[17]
-
Indonesia's fires released nearly 200 million tonnes of carbon this year, the EU's Copernicus service said on Thursday.
-
13
El Nino and king tides threaten California
What happened
-
Waves above 50 feet hit San Mateo County, California, last weekend, and seawater flooded yards in San Diego.
[18] -
Sea levels there are already at record highs.
[18] -
King tides, the highest tides of the year, arrive from 24 to 26 November and again 23 to 25 December.
[18] -
They happen when the Moon is closest to Earth at a monthly high tide.
[18]
How it unfolded
This El Nino could be the strongest in 1,000 years, Scientific American reports.
[18] - 24 to 26 Nov first king tides
- 23 to 25 Dec higher king tides
Why it matters
October high tides already made six Orange County homes unsafe to live in.
[18] Think it through
-
1
Why are the seas so high?
Several rises stack: warming has added 4 to 9 inches over a century.
[18] Warm water swelling adds 6 to 20 more.[18] Inches, top of each range
A century of warming9Warm water swelling20What is stacking on California's sea level -
2
So is this just one bad winter?
80% of California's erosion happens in El Nino winters, a coastal hydrologist says.
[18] 80%of erosion in El Nino winters
How it works
Ocean scientists call this thermal expansion: water takes up more room as it warms.
[18] Water off San Diego is over 10 degrees Fahrenheit warmer than usual, so its thermal expansion lifts the sea.
[18] Seen it before
A full bath overflows when you climb in.
The truth
- A storm that lines up with the king tides would make it worse, and storm timing is not known ahead.
[18]
-
Waves above 50 feet hit San Mateo County, California, last weekend, and seawater flooded yards in San Diego.
-
14
The Atacama Desert blooms after rare rain
What happened
-
The Atacama in northern Chile is one of the driest places on Earth.
[19] Parts of it turned purple, green and white with flowers.[19] -
Scientists say it may be the biggest flowering desert seen from satellites.
[19] -
Heavy rain from July woke seeds lying dormant in the soil.
[19] -
NASA's Landsat satellites photographed it on 14 September and 24 October.
[19]
How it unfolded
El Nino weakens the high pressure that normally keeps the region dry.
[19] - 14 September first images
- 24 October red-purple blooms
Why it matters
Chilean researchers are mapping the bloom to help planners protect it.
[19] Think it through
-
1
How rare is it?
Earlier satellite studies found 13 blooms between 1981 and 2015.
[19] This one is the most significant since remote sensing began, a plant geographer says.[19] 13blooms between 1981 and 2015
-
2
Isn't El Nino bad news elsewhere?
The same El Nino brings drought to Indonesia and high seas to California.
[17] [18] ChileflowersIndonesiafires
How it works
Meteorologists call it a storm track: the path storms usually follow.
[19] El Nino pushed the storm track toward the equator, so rain reached the Atacama.
[19] Seen it before
Seeds in a forgotten packet still sprout once you water them.
The truth
- Satellites only show the bloom since the 1980s, so older blooms cannot be compared.
[19]
Good news
- The desert is in its biggest bloom of the satellite era.
[19]
-
The Atacama in northern Chile is one of the driest places on Earth.
-
15
Hidden ocean heat may seed El Nino
What happened
-
A study published on Friday found two warm surges deep in the North Pacific travelled to the tropics.
[33] -
The surges began in 2009 and 2013 in the eastern North Pacific.
[33] -
They came before the 2015 and 2019 El Nino events and correlate strongly with them.
[33] -
The team, from Ocean University of China, used Argo ocean observations and water tracking.
[33]
Who is involved
- Ocean University of China did the study
How it unfolded
- 2009 first surge starts
- 2013 second surge starts
- 2013 surge starts
- 2015 El Nino
Why it matters
This year's El Nino could be the strongest in 1,000 years, Scientific American reports.
[18] Think it through
-
1
Why wasn't this heat noticed before?
Heat deep in the ocean interior has been largely unexplored, the authors say.
[33] -
2
Could it help forecast the next El Nino?
The authors call these warm extremes "a long-lived form of ocean memory".
[33]
How it works
Oceanographers call this ocean memory: heat stored at depth that shapes climate years later.
[33] The 2009 surge kept its heat at depth, and that ocean memory reached the tropics before the 2015 El Nino.
[33] Seen it before
A hot water bottle stays warm under the covers for hours.
The truth
- The study shows a correlation in two cases, not proof that surges cause El Nino.
[33]
-
A study published on Friday found two warm surges deep in the North Pacific travelled to the tropics.
-
16
Yemen's drivers pay for dirty petrol
What happened
-
Drivers in Sanaa, the Yemeni city the Houthis hold, say contaminated petrol is damaging their engines.
[16] -
The Houthis are the armed group that has controlled north-west Yemen since 2014.
[16] -
Twenty litres of petrol rose from 9,500 to 11,400 riyals, about $18 to $21, a rise of 20%.
[16] -
One taxi driver paid about $100 to fix a pump and clogged injectors.
[16]
Who is involved
- The Houthis control north-west Yemen since 2014
How it unfolded
Fuel imports through Houthi-held ports fell 73% from January to May, the World Bank says.
[16] Why it matters
Taxi drivers, farmers and delivery riders lose income when their vehicles break.
[16] Think it through
-
1
Why is the fuel dirty?
The Houthi-run fuel company says air strikes wrecked tanks in Hodeidah that cleaned the fuel.
[16] Strikes hit tanksFuel not cleanedDirty petrol -
2
Is that the whole story?
The Sana'a Center says import limits pushed the Houthis toward lower-quality Iranian fuel.
[16]
How it works
Engineers call this fuel contamination: impurities that clog the parts that spray fuel into the engine.
[16] In Sanaa the fuel contamination turns sticky in hot engines, clogging injectors and damaging valves.
[16] Seen it before
Pouring sugary drink through a straw leaves it sticky and blocked.
The truth
- The cause is disputed between the fuel company and its critics, and the article reports no test of the fuel.
[16]
-
Drivers in Sanaa, the Yemeni city the Houthis hold, say contaminated petrol is damaging their engines.
-
17
Scotland approves a 1GW floating wind farm
What happened
-
Scotland's government gave planning consent to Muir Mhor, one of the world's first commercial-scale floating wind farms.
[34] -
It sits about 63 kilometres off Peterhead and will generate up to 1 gigawatt.
[34] -
That is enough for about 1.2 million homes, the developer says.
[34]
How it unfolded
- Now both consents won
- Early 2030s first power
Why it matters
Aberdeenshire expects jobs in building, running and maintaining it.
[34] Think it through
-
1
Who owns it?
Fred Olsen Seawind, the developer, bought Vattenfall's half earlier this year.
[34] -
2
Does Scotland keep the money?
So far 18.4 million pounds of contracts have gone out, 7.96 million to Scottish firms.
[34] Million pounds
All contracts18.4Scottish firms7.96Muir Mhor's contracts so far
How it works
Planners call it consent: permission to build, given once the assessments are done.
Muir Mhor won consent after years of environmental assessments and talks with communities, the developer says.
[34] Seen it before
A school trip goes ahead only once every permission slip is signed.
The truth
- The early-2030s start is the developer's own plan; no building date is given.
[34]
Good news
- Scotland approved Muir Mhor, a floating wind farm off Peterhead that can power the equivalent of 1.2 million homes.
What comes next
Power is due in the early 2030s.
[34] -
Scotland's government gave planning consent to Muir Mhor, one of the world's first commercial-scale floating wind farms.
-
18
A record for a new kind of solar panel
What happened
-
Chinese researchers reached a certified 23.9% efficiency on a small perovskite solar module, a world record.
[35] -
Perovskite cells are a next-generation solar technology, not yet in wide use.
[35] -
The team was led by MicroQuanta, a Chinese firm, with Zhejiang University.
[35] -
The record is for a module of 19.48 square centimetres, not a tiny lab cell.
[35]
Who is involved
- MicroQuanta Chinese solar maker
- Zhejiang University research partner
Why it matters
Solar cells often lose efficiency when they are scaled up into modules.
[35] Think it through
-
1
How did they keep the efficiency?
They cooled the wet film before a vacuum step, slowing crystal growth.
[35] Cool the wet filmCrystals grow slowlyFewer losses -
2
Is it ready for rooftops?
Dongchen Lan of MicroQuanta says it addresses "a key challenge" in bringing these panels to practical use.
[35]
How it works
Engineers call this the scale-up problem: what works small often fails large.
[35] MicroQuanta tackled the scale-up problem at module size, where losses usually appear.
[35] Seen it before
A cake recipe for four can flop when you make it for forty.
The truth
- The team says it helps modules keep their performance over time, but gives no outdoor lifetime in the article.
[35]
Good news
- Next-generation solar panels moved a step closer to practical use.
[35]
-
Chinese researchers reached a certified 23.9% efficiency on a small perovskite solar module, a world record.
-
19
Tesla wants a tax break for a solar factory
What happened
-
Tesla has asked Texas for a property tax break for a $3.1 billion polysilicon plant near Robstown.
[36] -
Polysilicon is the ultra-pure silicon that solar cells are made from.
[36] -
Tesla says it would not build the plant in Texas without the tax break.
[36] -
More than 90% of the world's solar-grade polysilicon is made in China, Tesla's filing says.
[36]
How it unfolded
- 2027 building starts
- 2032 515 jobs
Why it matters
Local school taxes on the plant would be cut to zero from 2028 to 2030, then halved to 2040.
[36] Think it through
-
1
Why would Texas agree?
Tesla says it is weighing other places, so Texas competes for it.
[36] Tesla weighs placesTexas offers a breakPlant stays -
2
What does Texas get back?
Tesla's adviser EY estimates $63.5 billion of economic output in Texas through 2065.
[36] $63.5 billionof output, Tesla's adviser estimates
How it works
Economists call this tax competition: places bid against each other with tax cuts for investment.
Tesla invites tax competition by saying it is assessing other states.
[36] Seen it before
Two shops cutting prices to win the same customer is the same idea.
The truth
- The $63.5 billion figure was prepared for Tesla, not by an independent body.
[36]
What comes next
Building would run from 2027 to 2030, with 515 jobs once running in 2032.
[36] -
Tesla has asked Texas for a property tax break for a $3.1 billion polysilicon plant near Robstown.
-
20
Free home batteries for 125 families
What happened
-
National Grid, a utility in Massachusetts, will put free home batteries in 125 low-income homes.
[37] -
The homes are in Fall River, a former mill city where median income is about half the state's.
[37] -
Each battery gives at least four hours of backup power.
[37] Families also get $150 a year for five years.[37] -
Haven Energy installs and runs the batteries, sharing their power with the grid at busy times.
[37]
Why it matters
Batteries working together can cut the need for pricier, dirtier plants.
[37] Think it through
-
1
Who pays for free batteries?
Haven earns money by enrolling the batteries in state grid programmes.
[37] Batteries enrolledState programmes payFamilies pay nothing -
2
Why these streets?
The pilot targets 1.2 megawatts along three weak power lines.
[37] It tests whether batteries can ease strain on one part of the grid.[37] 1.2 MWof batteries on three weak lines
How it works
Engineers call this a virtual power plant: many small batteries run together like one plant.
Fall River's virtual power plant pools 125 batteries to help where lines are weakest.
[37] Seen it before
Many small piggy banks together can pay for one bike.
The truth
- It is a pilot: whether low-income families will sign up at scale is what it tests.
[37]
Good news
- 125 families get free backup power and $150 a year for five years.
[37]
-
National Grid, a utility in Massachusetts, will put free home batteries in 125 low-income homes.
-
21
A storm cuts power on the Eyre Peninsula
What happened
-
A storm toppled three power transmission towers on South Australia's Eyre Peninsula on Thursday.
[38] -
About 24,000 properties lost power.
[38] Local generators restored about 10,000 customers around Port Lincoln that night.[38] -
ElectraNet, which runs the state's high-voltage lines, says the towers were built for winds of 170 kilometres an hour.
[38] -
8 hospitals ran on backup generators, and 34 schools stayed closed on Friday.
[38] -
The state government told the market operator to seek spare generation under an emergency declaration.
[38]
How it unfolded
- 2 to 3 weeks temporary lines
- After that new towers
Why it matters
Farmers in the middle of harvest fear heavy losses, and more storms are forecast for the weekend.
[38] Think it through
-
1
Why wasn't there a backup line?
A second line beside it would have doubled the cost, ElectraNet says.
[38] That cost would land on South Australian households.[38] One linethe cost paidTwo linesdouble the cost -
2
So who pays for the repairs?
Customers will pay for repairs at some level, ElectraNet says, but far less than for a second line.
[38] -
3
So who decides how strong the next line is?
Lines must pass a regulator's value-for-money test before the spending is allowed, ElectraNet says.
[38] A planThe regulator's testSpending allowed
How it works
Engineers call this redundancy: a second path that keeps power flowing when the first one fails.
The Eyre line had no redundancy, because a second circuit would have doubled its cost to customers.
[38] Seen it before
A village with one road in is cut off when a tree falls across it.
The truth
- ElectraNet says the towers met a one-in-2,000-year standard and this storm was stronger.
[38] The state's energy minister had called its $300 million upgrades "failed".[38]
What comes next
Temporary lines will take 2 to 3 weeks, and only then will the fallen towers be replaced.
[38] -
A storm toppled three power transmission towers on South Australia's Eyre Peninsula on Thursday.
-
22
A $1 billion US battery deal
What happened
-
Sila, a US maker of battery materials, signed a deal to supply Panasonic Energy, a global battery manufacturer.
[39] -
Sila says the deal could be worth more than $1 billion over time.
[39] -
Sila makes silicon-based anodes for lithium-ion batteries.
[39] Its anode weighs a fifth as much as the graphite used today.[39] -
That lets a battery hold more energy for its weight, giving electric cars longer range.
[39] -
The deal will help Sila's factory in Moses Lake, Washington, make at least 10 times more.
[39]
Who is involved
- Panasonic Energy makes batteries, the buyer
- 24M bankrupt
- ESS Tech bankrupt
How it unfolded
Two billion-dollar US battery firms, 24M and ESS Tech, went bankrupt in the last year.
[39] Why it matters
China controls over 90% of the world's graphite production.
[39] A US-made anode gives buyers another source.[39] Think it through
-
1
Who is paying for the factory?
A $1.4 billion loan from the US Defense Department backs much of the factory's production.
[39] $1.4 billionloan from the US Defense Department
-
2
Why is the military paying for batteries?
The department called it a "significant technology sovereignty challenge".
[39] Sila's announcement mentions electric cars but not climate.[39] -
3
So who holds the leverage?
China holds the graphite, so the US government is paying to build a rival supply at home.
[39]
How it works
Engineers call it energy density: how much energy a battery holds for its weight and size.
[39] Sila's anode raises energy density: a fifth the weight of graphite and half the volume, the company says.
[39] Seen it before
A lighter backpack lets you carry more books for the same effort.
The truth
- Sila has not shared the tonnage or the price, so the $1 billion is its own estimate.
[39]
-
Sila, a US maker of battery materials, signed a deal to supply Panasonic Energy, a global battery manufacturer.
More Climate editions
Across the beats