Gaming · Monday, 31 August 2026
Four buyers say Sony sold them games they do not own. Sony says everybody already knew.
A class action in the US state of California turns on one word on a button. Sony's answer is that no reasonable person thinks Buy Now means buy - and it is arguing that as the industry stops printing discs.
91%
of European games revenue in 2025 came from downloads rather than discs or cartridges
the industry body Video Games Europe surveyed 39,371 people across 16 countries
Jan 2028
when Sony stops producing PlayStation game discs altogether
after that its games exist only as the licence the four buyers say was never explained
7 days
the logoff protest PS5 owners organised, 23 to 30 August
players were asked to buy nothing, download nothing and play nothing for the week
The lead story — what happened
-
Four PlayStation customers sued Sony on 18 June, saying it never made clear that buying a digital game gets you a licence and not ownership.
[1] -
Sony's answer, reported in late August, is that reasonable consumers would not be misled, because its user agreement says software is licensed to you, not sold.
[1] -
The buttons in the store say Buy Now and Confirm Purchase; the sentence that changes what those words mean sits inside thousands of lines of terms.
[1] -
A law passed in the US state of California in 2024 bans using buy or purchase for a digital good unless the seller adds a clear and conspicuous notice that the buyer will not own it.
[1] -
In late August Sony emailed PlayStation owners a reminder of those same terms, in the middle of a week-long protest in which PS5 owners were urged to log off entirely, 23 to 30 August.
[1] [2] -
The protest is about Sony's decision, announced in July, to stop producing PlayStation game discs from January 2028, after which its games are sold as downloads only.
[2] -
Rockstar's Grand Theft Auto 6, out on 19 November, will also ship without a disc, and hackers leaking the game said at first they were trying to force Rockstar to change that.
[3] -
Xbox is saying the opposite out loud: its chief executive Asha Sharma says players love physical media and points to a new feature that turns discs a player already owns into digital copies.
[5] -
The shift is close to finished either way - 91% of European games revenue in 2025 came from digital purchases rather than discs or cartridges.
[15] -
Nobody in the case argues that a licence cannot be withdrawn. The fight is only over whether the word on the button described what was being sold.
[1]
Who is involved
-
Sony Interactive Entertainment
the Japanese company behind PlayStation, the best-selling console line; it is the defendant here
-
The four buyers
PlayStation customers who filed on 18 June for themselves and everyone in the same position
-
California's lawmakers
the legislature of the biggest US state; in 2024 they banned the word buy on a digital good without a clear ownership notice
-
Stop Killing Games
a players' campaign arguing companies should not switch off games people paid for; it has been picking up support [2]
-
Asha Sharma
Xbox's chief executive; she says players love physical media and that Xbox will keep giving them a choice [5]
What is pushing on this
a week-long logoff protest ran 23 to 30 August over the end of discs
91% of European games revenue is already digital, and Sony stops printing discs in 2028
California's 2024 law bans buy on a digital good without a clear notice at the point of sale
it says the terms are explicit and emailed every owner a reminder of them
How it unfolded
- 2024 California bans the word buy on a digital good without a clear ownership notice
- Jul 2026 Sony says it will stop producing PlayStation game discs from January 2028
- 18 Jun four customers file a class action saying Sony hid that games are licensed, not sold
- 23-30 Aug PS5 owners run a week-long logoff protest over the end of discs
- Late Aug Sony emails owners the licence terms and argues in court that no reasonable buyer was misled
Where this points
The test is whether a court accepts a clause inside the terms as the clear notice California's law asks for at the moment of purchase. If it does not, every Buy button selling into that state has to change its wording.
The rest of the day
40 more stories on this beat.
Each with its own sources. None of these is a link to the story above.
-
02
Switch 2 price rises on 1 September
Nintendo's Switch 2 goes from $449.99 to $499.99 in the US on 1 September, with rises the same week in Canada, the UK and mainland Europe. Nintendo announced the increase back in May and blamed market conditions.
[7] [8] Why it matters — PlayStation, Xbox and Valve have all raised prices over the past year; Nintendo is the last of the four to move.
-
03
Nintendo kept its tariff refund
After the US Supreme Court struck down the 2025 tariffs, the Trump administration refunded the companies that had paid them; Nintendo received about $300 million and said the payout helped push it to a large quarterly profit. It also said customers are not legally entitled to a rebate.
[9] [11] Why it matters — Panic, which makes the Playdate handheld, automatically refunded every customer who had paid its tariff surcharge - the same money, two different answers.
-
04
New chip tariffs under consideration
Politico reported that the Trump administration is weighing duties on imported chips and on the goods built from them, which would include consoles, laptops and data-centre servers. US commerce secretary Howard Lutnick is said to want tariff relief tied to building factories inside the US.
[9] [10] Why it matters — The specifics are unsettled, but console makers have to price the possibility now rather than when it lands.
-
05
Consoles already far above launch prices
The PlayStation 5 now costs $150 more than at launch and the Xbox Series X $300 more, driven by a memory shortage created by the rush to build AI data centres.
[9] Why it matters — Gaming is buying the same chips as an industry with far deeper pockets, and losing.
-
06
A $899 anniversary Xbox
Microsoft priced its translucent green 25th-anniversary Xbox at $899, with preorders from 27 August and release on 13 November. Under the shell it is an Xbox Series X with 1TB of storage and a copy of Halo: Combat Evolved.
[12] Why it matters — The hardware is unchanged; the price is for the colour and the anniversary.
-
07
Xbox says the next console must be cheap
Xbox chief executive Asha Sharma told the BBC that the whole industry needs to innovate on affordability, something it has never had to do before. Xbox revenue fell 7%, about $1.7 billion, in the last financial year, and a further 1,600 job cuts are expected by the end of this one.
[5] [6] Why it matters — A platform that spent two decades competing on power is now competing on price.
-
08
Games market forecast at $213.9bn
Newzoo expects the global games market to grow 6.1% this year to $213.9 billion, with mobile taking the largest share at 57% and $121.1 billion, console 22% and PC 21%. Over half of all consumer spending comes from China and the US.
[13] Why it matters — The full report lands on 10 September. A separate FastSpring and Omdia survey found 96% of studios now run or plan their own web store.
-
09
Console growth is one game
Newzoo's market intelligence director Manu Rosier said that without Grand Theft Auto 6 launching this year, console revenue would be flat against 2025 rather than up 5.1%. He also expects the game to be cannibalistic to others.
[14] Why it matters — It explains why so many studios moved their release dates out of November.
-
10
European revenue at 30 billion euros
Video Games Europe put the continent's 2025 games revenue at 30 billion euros across 16 countries, with 91% of it digital. But in the five original markets it has tracked longest, revenue fell 4% to 25.7 billion euros.
[15] Why it matters — The headline total grew by adding eleven more countries, not by the old ones growing.
-
11
First dip in European games jobs
A separate industry report counted 24 billion euros of turnover across the EU in 2024, from 6,600 studios and more than 95,000 workers, and recorded the sector's first employment fall. In 2025 the EU and UK together held 123,000 people across 8,700 studios, 24% of them women.
[15] [16] Why it matters — Studio numbers keep rising while headcount stalls: more companies, each smaller.
-
12
Splitgate studio quits live service
1047 Games ended active development on Empulse and Splitgate: Arena Reloaded, saying neither made enough money to cover the cost of dedicated servers. From 3 September both switch to peer-to-peer hosting with a server browser, so players host their own matches.
[17] [18] [19] Why it matters — Rather than switch the games off, the studio removed the part that needed a company alive to run it.
-
13
Riot winds down 2XKO and refunds
Riot Games will end active development of its fighting game 2XKO in December, saying not enough players stuck with it. It is unlocking every character, bundling most cosmetic items, and refunding all money spent in the game on or before 20 August.
[20] Why it matters — Servers stay on, so the game keeps working; what stops is the reason to keep buying things in it.
-
14
Schell Games cuts 14 jobs
Schell Games laid off around 14 people, according to posts by affected staff including its marketing director and senior public relations manager. Founder Jesse Schell had argued publicly in 2024 that layoffs are avoidable and that his studio risks cash, not jobs.
[21] Why it matters — The clearest public statement in the industry against layoffs did not survive contact with this year.
-
15
Double Fine owns its games again
Double Fine has regained ownership of its intellectual property and its publishing rights after being spun out of Xbox. Chief executive Tim Schafer said some of its games still say Microsoft on them, but that sales now support the studio.
[22] Why it matters — It was spun out during the cuts that hit more than 3,200 Xbox staff, and came out with the one asset that matters.
-
16
Journey studio starts publishing
Thatgamecompany, which made Journey and Sky: Children of the Light, launched thatgamepublisher, funded from Sky's profits and with a couple of games already signed. Its head SJ Xue said there are no genre, platform, size or stage restrictions.
[23] [24] Why it matters — Co-founder Jenova Chen's explanation is blunt: a hit gives a small studio money it does not want to spend on becoming a big studio, so it invests in what it understands.
-
17
A talent agency launches a games fund
The Hollywood talent agency CAA launched Frame1Games to fund, accelerate and market independent games, with a curated marketplace and mentoring from agency executives. Support at industry events starts in 2027.
[11] Why it matters — It joins Outersloth, Kinetic, Pocketpair and Evil Landfall - indie hits and outsiders are both funding indie games now.
-
18
Godot's commercial arm raises $18m
W4 Games, set up by the founders of the free Godot engine to sell services around it, raised $18 million and signed a deal with the Chinese giant Tencent to reach Asia. It has about 30 staff and plans to grow headcount by half.
[25] Why it matters — 1,262 Godot games have shipped on Steam so far in 2026, and the engine's second-biggest user bases are China and Japan.
-
19
Dublin start-up bets on browsers
Entity, founded by the team behind Star Trek Fleet Command, raised $5 million to build a platform for console-quality games running in a browser, using WebGPU and WebAssembly. It plans to launch in 2027.
[26] Why it matters — The pitch is aimed squarely at the console price problem: play without buying the box.
-
20
Mobile giant plans to double again
MTG, the Swedish owner of Raid: Shadow Legends after a $620 million purchase of Plarium, says it wants to double in size again within three to five years, and will need more acquisitions to do it.
[27] Why it matters — Mobile growth has slowed from double digits to single digits, so growing now means taking share from someone else or buying them.
-
21
Saudi broadcaster builds a games studio
MBC, the Saudi media group in which the state-owned Public Investment Fund took a 54% stake in 2025, is building a game called 1001 Threads of Mizan and demoed it at Gamescom. An MBC executive, Engelhardt, said the studio currently has a policy against using generative AI.
[28] Why it matters — The same fund's role in the Electronic Arts buyout drew objections from US politicians and from people inside the industry.
-
22
Saber: stop building only for North America
Saber's chief creative officer Tim Willits told Game Developer the industry must look beyond North America and find reliable income to support its big swings.
[29] Why it matters — It is the same argument the market data makes: over half of spending now comes from China and the US, and the growth is not in the old markets.
-
23
Generated art all over the Gamescom show
More than a dozen studios shown at Gamescom Opening Night Live had used generative AI somewhere in development or marketing, according to reporting and a widely shared thread. The show sells roughly 60 seconds of stage time for about $120,000.
[11] Why it matters — A showcase funded by the studios it shows has no easy way to be a filter for them.
-
24
Witcher 3 gets a third expansion
At Opening Night Live, CD Projekt Red announced a third expansion for The Witcher 3, called Songs of the Past and due in 2027. It is giving the first two expansions free to owners of the base game. Chinese and Korean studios were unusually prominent through the show.
[30] [31] Why it matters — A game from 2015 is still worth building for, and its two older expansions become free to anyone who owns it.
-
25
A game trailer crashed Netflix
Netflix's US mobile viewership rose 35% during the 30-minute Grand Theft Auto 6 preview it streamed exclusively, and web traffic ran 125% above average, enough to take the site down. Sensor Tower puts pre-orders at 4.6 million, 77% of them on PlayStation 5, the platform the preview was captured on. IGN's buying guide for the game walks through PS5, PS5 Pro and Xbox pricing.
[32] [4] Why it matters — Netflix shut two of its own game studios and is now selling other people's games to its 325 million subscribers instead.
[3] -
26
GTA 6 heads for a $1bn budget
Rockstar has never published a figure, but analysts estimate Grand Theft Auto 6 has cost well over $1 billion, with some putting it around $1.5 billion, after roughly a decade in active development. Sony's Horizon Forbidden West cost $212 million by comparison. A New York Times reporter watched nearly 27 minutes of the game inside Rockstar North's building in Edinburgh.
[33] [34] Why it matters — Film budgets are the wrong yardstick now; a game runs longer and needs a testing team as well as a production one.
-
27
Xbox kept its Game Pass promise
When Xbox raised Game Pass Ultimate to $30 a month in October 2025 it promised more than 75 day-one releases a year. GameSpot tracked every title and found the target met, on 27 August 2026.
[35] Why it matters — It is the one commitment that survived a year that included a new chief executive, thousands of layoffs and several studios spun out.
-
28
Witcher 4 already runs on every console
CD Projekt Red co-chief executive Michal Nowakowski said The Witcher 4 currently launches and runs on PC, PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X, and that the studio stops to fix anything broken on any one of them.
[36] Why it matters — Cyberpunk 2077 was built PC-first on the belief that scaling down later would be easy; it was pulled from the PlayStation store instead.
-
29
Hacker wipes a game's player data
Secret Neighbor, the multiplayer spin-off of Hello Neighbor, was taken offline after someone obtained admin credentials, deleted player profiles and progression, and demanded the game be removed from sale everywhere. Developer Hologryph and publisher tinyBuild called it a coordinated attack.
[37] Why it matters — The game stays down until the breach is fixed, so a security failure and a shutdown look identical from a player's side.
-
30
AI used to crack a fan server
Star Wars Galaxies Legends, a community-run version of the shut-down MMO, said a Reddit moderator used AI tools to decrypt its custom game assets and has offered them to rival servers. The dispute reportedly goes back 14 years.
[38] Why it matters — The people keeping a dead game alive have no company behind them and no way to enforce anything.
-
31
State of Decay 3 opens a beta
Undead Labs will run a closed beta for State of Decay 3 before the end of 2026, after an alpha that it says improved combat, cosmetics, visuals and movement. Creative director Kevin Patzelt cited the studio's largest map and untethered multiplayer as the reason for stress-testing.
[39] Why it matters — The studio was one of those spun out of Xbox this year, and this is its first public checkpoint since.
-
32
Persona 6 discs only on PlayStation
Sega's Japanese page for Persona 6 lists PlayStation 5, Windows PC and Xbox Series X, with physical copies exclusive to the PlayStation 5 version. Xbox sells far less in Japan.
[40] Why it matters — The physical edition follows the platform with the players, and in Japan that is not a close call.
-
33
PlayStation Plus September line-up
Sony revealed September's Essential games for PlayStation Plus subscribers: Chained Echoes, Sniper Elite: Resistance, Wobbly Life and MLB The Show 26, downloadable from 1 September.
[41] Why it matters — Nobody thinks a subscription game is theirs to keep. The lead story is about whether a bought one is.
-
34
Japan's rival to D&D goes English
Sword World RPG, created by Group SNE in 1989 and a mainstay of Japanese tabletop gaming for decades, is getting its first official English translation from Mugen Gaming.
[42] Why it matters — Dungeons and Dragons' claim to be the world's most famous role-playing game has never been true in Japan.
-
35
Slovakia moves to bar under-16s
Slovakia's government approved a bill on 26 August that would ban children under 16 from setting up social network accounts, and would require users to prove their age. The report with it cites addictive behaviour, social pressure and radicalisation.
[43] Why it matters — The bill does not name games, but age checks written for social accounts reach the same platforms games are streamed and argued about on.
-
36
The machines that are games on paper
So-called skill games in the US state of Pennsylvania look and pay like slot machines. Their designers add one feature to escape gambling rules: a losing player may switch to another game to win the points back. Many players never use it.
[44] Why it matters — A single unused option is doing all the legal work, the same way an unread clause does in the lead story.
-
37
Thefts at Gamescom, and a whip-round
At least two thefts were reported at Gamescom, including all of independent developer Ryan Laley's equipment, taken from his booth. CD Projekt Red offered to send him hardware and a marketing consultant paid to replace what he lost.
[45] Why it matters — A solo developer's entire show can sit in one bag, and there is no insurer of last resort for that.
-
38
Ubisoft sets up a Player Council
Ubisoft soft-launched a Player Council at Gamescom, inviting players to test early concepts, prototypes and live games and to talk directly to developers. It opens with four projects: the released games Riders Republic and Atomega, and two known only by codenames.
[46] Why it matters — The company chooses who joins and what they see, which decides what feedback it can receive.
-
39
A Switch 2 exclusive out-drew Elden Ring
From Software producer Yasuhiro Kitao said sign-ups for The Duskbloods playtest beat those for Elden Ring Nightreign, despite Duskbloods being exclusive to the newer and smaller Switch 2 audience. We were really surprised, he said.
[47] Why it matters — A free sign-up measures curiosity rather than willingness to pay, but it is the only number a studio gets before it commits.
-
40
Carmack would have used AI, says ex-partner
A former co-owner of id Software, the studio behind Doom, said the team would absolutely have used generative AI in its early days, joking that John Carmack would be building Skynet.
[48] Why it matters — The industry argument is usually framed as old craft against new tools; this is one of the oldest names arguing the other way.
-
41
The other end of the mobile market
A Guardian columnist described falling into free mobile games built on energy timers and advert breaks, where each run costs a ticket and running out means waiting twenty minutes or watching a video.
[49] Why it matters — This is where the 57% mobile share and $121.1 billion actually come from, and it is a different business from the one the lawsuit is about.
[13]
When everybody does it, nobody was misled
A practice that spreads far enough stops needing a defence, because the fact that it is everywhere becomes the proof that nobody was surprised.
The twist
A practice stops needing to be explained once it is common enough, because its own spread becomes the evidence that nobody could have been caught out by it.
How it works
- A shop puts a friendly word on the button: Buy Now
- The terms that contradict it sit in a document nobody opens
- Enough shops do the same thing that it stops looking odd
- A buyer complains they were misled
- The shop answers that everybody already knew
- The practice being everywhere is what proves nobody was surprised
Where you've seen this
Ticket websites
a fee that only appears on the last screen is now standard, so nobody can say they did not expect one
Job contracts
a clause every employer uses stops reading like a term and starts reading like the weather
Cookie boxes
clicking through without reading is universal, and the click still counts as agreement
The catch
It breaks when a law sets the test from outside. California's 2024 rule asks whether the notice was clear at the moment of purchase, not whether everyone already knew.
And the whole of it
Everybody here is behaving normally: the buyer who clicks through, the lawyer who drafts the clause, the shop that copies the shop next door. Most of us have agreed to hundreds of things this way, and that is the same fact Sony is handing to the court.
What is really going on
Sony is not arguing that it told buyers what they were getting; it is arguing that every digital shop works this way, so nobody could have been surprised.
Why it works on us — The word on the button does the persuading and the clause in the agreement does the defending, and a buyer only ever meets one of them.
Who gains
-
Sony
— If a court accepts that the terms were clear enough, its shift to downloads only in 2028 goes ahead without changing a word in the store.
[1] [2] -
Every other digital storefront
— A ruling for Sony settles the same question for anyone selling software behind a Buy button, without their having to argue it themselves.
[1] -
Nintendo
— It kept about $300 million in tariff refunds, said buyers have no legal claim on the money, and raises the Switch 2 price by $50 on 1 September.
[9] [11] [7] -
Netflix
— Streaming somebody else's game trailer lifted its US mobile viewership 35% and its web traffic 125%, after its own game studios were shut.
[32] [3] -
W4 Games
— It sold investors and Tencent the growth of an engine it gives away, on the strength of 1,262 Godot releases on Steam this year.
[25]
Who pays
-
PlayStation buyers who wanted a disc
— From January 2028 there is no disc to buy, and the case is about whether the replacement was ever properly described.
[1] [2] -
Console buyers
— The PlayStation 5 costs $150 more than at launch, the Xbox Series X $300 more, and the Switch 2 goes up $50 on 1 September.
[9] [7] -
The 14 people cut at Schell Games
— They were let go by a studio whose founder had publicly built its finances around risking cash rather than jobs.
[21] -
Players of Empulse and Splitgate: Arena Reloaded
— Dedicated servers and matchmaking stop on 3 September; finding a game now depends on another player hosting one.
[17] [18] -
Studios at Gamescom that used no generated art
— They shared a stage with more than a dozen that did, and the show drew no line between them.
[11]
What nobody knows yet
Open questions from across today’s stories — ours included.
-
01
Whether a licence clause inside the terms counts as the clear and conspicuous notice California's 2024 law demands.
The law requires the notice at the moment of purchase, and no court has yet ruled on what that means for a linked agreement.
[1] -
02
How many PlayStation buyers a ruling would cover.
The four named plaintiffs filed on behalf of everyone in the same position, and neither side has published a number.
[1] -
03
Whether the new US tariffs will cover consoles at all.
The reporting describes the framework as unsettled and says it could change drastically over the coming months.
[9] [10] -
04
Which way European games revenue is actually going.
Video Games Europe reports 30 billion euros for 2025 across 16 countries, while the five markets it has tracked longest fell 4% to 25.7 billion euros - the total grew by adding countries. A separate report puts EU turnover at 24 billion euros for 2024 on a different footprint again.
[15] [16] -
05
Whether Empulse and Splitgate: Arena Reloaded stay findable after 3 September.
Peer-to-peer hosting keeps them running, but 1047 Games has not said how many players are left to host matches.
[17] [18] -
06
Whether the cuts at Schell Games stop at 14.
The count comes from affected employees' own posts; the studio has not commented, and has not said whether more follow.
[21] -
07
Who paid whom for the Grand Theft Auto 6 preview on Netflix.
Neither Netflix nor Take-Two has said whether Netflix bought the exclusive or Take-Two bought the audience.
[3] -
08
How much generative AI went into the games shown at Gamescom.
The count of more than a dozen studios comes from journalists and a social-media thread, not from the studios, most of which did not disclose it.
[11]
Ryan Laley, an independent developer, had all his equipment stolen from his booth at Gamescom. A marketing consultant who goes by Indie Game Joe paid to replace it, and CD Projekt Red offered to send him some of its own gear.
More from Gaming
Across the beats