Mind & Body · Monday, 19 October 2026
NHS leaders say up to 20 of England's 155 consultant-led maternity units may have to shut or change role
The NHS Alliance says a shortage of obstetricians and a jump in caesarean births mean some small units cannot run safely around the clock, while north Devon's unit stays shut.
20 of 155
consultant-led maternity units in England that may shut or change role
the Health Service Journal put the number at risk at 24 in August
33% to 45%
share of births in England by caesarean, from 2020 to last year
a caesarean needs an operating theatre and a surgeon on hand
53 miles
from Barnstaple to Exeter, where north Devon's babies are now born
one Exmoor mother left home before her contractions began, so as not to give birth in a car park
194
women estimated to have given birth in Exeter because of the closure
by late August the trust had counted 54, none born on the way
The lead story — what happened
-
Matthew Hopkins, a director at the NHS Alliance, says up to 20 of England's 155 consultant-led maternity units will have to shut or change role.
[1] [3] -
The NHS Alliance represents most of the NHS trusts that run hospitals in England.
[3] A consultant-led unit is one run by obstetricians, the senior doctors who handle difficult births.[1] -
The units most at risk deliver 1,500 to 2,000 babies a year, and many are in rural or coastal areas where staff are hardest to find.
[1] [2] -
Hopkins blames two things: too few obstetricians across the NHS, and a sharp rise in caesarean births, which need more staff and more operating theatres.
[1] -
Caesareans rose from 33% of births in England in 2020 to 45% last year.
[3] -
MBRRACE-UK, which investigates mothers' deaths, found that some women who died between 2022 and 2024 had their caesarean delayed because no surgeon or theatre was free.
[3] -
The Royal College of Midwives says families rely on units close to home.
[1] The Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists says there are safer answers to the staff shortage than closing units.[1] -
One unit on the Health Service Journal's list of 24 at risk has already stopped births: North Devon District Hospital in Barnstaple, shut since 11 August for lack of senior doctors.
[3] [6] -
Women from north Devon now make a 53-mile trip to Exeter to give birth, and an estimated 194 have done so.
[4] [1] -
The Barnstaple unit stayed shut after a check this month, and its trust is expected to decide this week whether it can reopen.
[4] [1] -
Devon County Council's leader, Julian Brazil, called the Barnstaple closure 'a catastrophic failure of senior management'.
[27] -
A government taskforce chaired by Yvette Cooper, England's health secretary, will publish a maternity plan before Christmas.
[3] Hopkins says hospital bosses fear it will avoid closures because of the political backlash.[1] [3]
Who is involved
-
Matthew Hopkins
director for acute care at the NHS Alliance, which represents most NHS trusts in England; he has run four hospital trusts and wants up to 20 units merged or shut
-
Royal College of Midwives
the professional body for midwives; its policy chief, Hannah Leonard, says high-quality units must stay close to home
-
Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists
the professional body for obstetricians; its president, Dr Alison Wright, says safer answers than closures exist
-
Royal Devon University Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust
the NHS body that runs the Barnstaple hospital; it suspended births there on 11 August
-
Yvette Cooper
England's health secretary; she chairs the maternity taskforce due to report before Christmas
How it unfolded
-
28 Jul Barnstaple's trust says it will not have enough senior doctors to deliver babies after 11 August
[6] -
11 Aug Births stop at North Devon District Hospital
[4] -
Aug The trust's medical director, Dr Karen Davies, resigns over how the closure was handled
[8] -
1 Sep The trust sets 29 September as a hoped-for reopening date
[7] -
13 Oct The unit stays shut after its latest readiness check
[4] -
19 Oct Hopkins says up to 20 units in England must shut or change role
[1]
Where this points
Watch the Royal Devon trust's decision on Barnstaple this week, and whether the taskforce report before Christmas names units to merge or leaves each trust to decide.
What is pushing on the whole day
The bar and the word are our reading of how hard each one is pushing today. The arrow is where it is heading. The evidence is in the stories below.
NHS leaders in England say small maternity units cannot staff safe care around the clock.
The NHS Alliance says some maternity units have too few theatres and beds, in old and decaying buildings.
Poorer parts of England have dirtier air than richer ones, research by the Institute for Fiscal Studies shows.
The rest of the day
11 more stories on this beat.
Each with its own sources. None of these is a link to the story above.
-
02
Northern Ireland's rural hospitals push back
Four hospital campaign groups have written to Northern Ireland's Executive, its power-sharing government, asking for a working group on rural health care.
[11] They say people in the countryside face long, unsafe trips for emergency care.[11] Daisy Hill Hospital in Newry, which lost its emergency surgery in 2024, could stop delivering babies from 23 November.[11] Its trust cannot recruit consultant obstetricians and plans to move births to Craigavon Area Hospital, about 40 minutes away.[12] [13] Why it matters — Northern Ireland's health minister, Robbie Butler, said in September that no final decision on Daisy Hill had been taken.
[12] Kara Finnegan, whose baby needed an emergency caesarean when her placenta came away, says a longer trip would put mothers like her at risk.[13] -
03
Essex midwives paid for gas exposure
More than 120 midwives and maternity staff at Basildon University Hospital in Essex will share 735,000 pounds in compensation.
[18] Poor ventilation let nitrous oxide, the gas and air given to women in labour, build up on the ward from 2021 to 2023.[18] Some staff breathed up to 30 times the legal workplace limit.[18] They were not told about test results showing this for 16 months.[18] The Royal College of Midwives says the gas is safe for mothers, and the fault was the ward.[18] Legal limit1 xHighest exposure30 xSome Basildon staff breathed gas at up to 30 times the legal workplace limit. Why it matters — Staff describe headaches, brain fog and low vitamin B12, and the union has written to every NHS trust in England about the risk.
[18] The NHS Alliance also blames old maternity buildings for unsafe care.[2] -
04
NHS England's own report flags harm to trans patients
An internal NHS England impact assessment, seen by the Guardian, says its new ward rules could cause delays and more corridor care, meaning treatment on trolleys in hallways, for trans patients.
[14] The rules, published on 15 October, say single-sex wards are used by biological sex, not gender identity.[14] The assessment says trans people may fear being outed, and some may avoid health care altogether.[14] It also lists benefits, including for women who are pregnant or breastfeeding.[14] Why it matters — It warns that hospitals may not have side rooms free, which would put trans patients on wards matching their biological sex.
[14] NHS England declined to comment.[14] -
05
New Zealand votes on a strained health service
New Zealand holds a general election on 7 November.
[16] Some 44% of New Zealanders name healthcare as a top concern, second only to the cost of living, says Ipsos, a polling firm.[15] One adult in four says they cannot get to see their family doctor, and record numbers are going to emergency departments.[15] New Zealand's government has hired 54 extra full-time nurses, not the 2,000 it promised.[15] Health minister Simeon Brown says waits for planned operations have improved.[15] Why it matters — Labour promises three free family-doctor visits and free prescriptions, and National promises 604 million dollars more for medicines.
[15] A recent poll put the two main parties level on 28%.[15] -
06
Scientists ask for an air pollution inquiry
A letter signed by 150 scientists, MPs and campaigners, including Greta Thunberg, asks Prime Minister Andy Burnham for a national inquiry into the unequal harm from air pollution.
[17] Research by the Institute for Fiscal Studies, a think tank, found poorer areas of England have dirtier air.[17] It found minority-ethnic groups breathe about 6% more pollution than white groups.[17] Figures gathered by Mums for Lungs, a campaign group, show over 200,000 children in 11 English areas went to hospital with breathing trouble in 2025.[17] 202365320251,072Babies and toddlers taken to hospital with breathing trouble in the city of Manchester. Why it matters — Children are hit hardest because their lungs are still growing and they breathe more air for their size.
[17] In the city of Manchester, hospital visits by babies and toddlers rose from 653 in 2023 to 1,072 in 2025.[17] -
07
Mild deafness in children is often missed
About 48% of the UK's more than 53,000 deaf children have mild hearing loss or hear with only one ear, says the National Deaf Children's Society, a charity.
[19] In its recent survey, only 36% of people agreed this can have a big effect on a child's day.[19] One in five thought it had little or no effect.[19] These children can struggle to pick out one voice from background noise, as in a classroom.[19] Arlo, eight, from Cottingham, was not diagnosed until she was two.[19] Why it matters — Simple changes, such as a seat near the teacher, help these children follow lessons, the charity says.
[19] Its campaign, launched this month, aims to help parents spot the signs.[19] -
08
A brain enzyme guards memory in old mice
A team including Amar Sahay at Massachusetts General Hospital found an enzyme that seems to protect memory as mice age.
[20] An enzyme is a protein that speeds up a chemical job, and this one breaks down fats; its gene is called Pla2g2f.[20] Mice without the gene had more brain inflammation and nerve damage as they aged.[20] Old mice with extra scored better on memory tests.[20] In donated human brains, the gene was most active in people who stayed sharp despite amyloid, a protein linked to Alzheimer's.[20] Why it matters — The work appeared on 15 October in Nature Neuroscience, and most of it was done in mice.
[20] Timothy Hohman, a brain scientist at Vanderbilt University who was not involved, called it a thoughtful way to find what protects nerve cells.[20] -
09
Brown fat linked to better health in scans
Researchers led by Rockefeller University in New York used AI to search the medical records of 101,243 people for brown fat.
[21] Brown fat is a kind of body fat that burns extra sugar and fat and helps control body temperature.[21] The nearly 8,900 people with visible brown fat were less likely to have type 2 diabetes, heart disease, anxiety or depression.[21] People on blood pressure pills more often had it, and in mice the drug losartan made brown fat burn more energy.[21] Why it matters — The links do not show that brown fat causes the better health, and the drug's effect has only been seen in mice.
[21] The researchers hope to find a way to switch brown fat on in people with normal blood pressure.[21] -
10
Antibodies may trigger some early births
About one pregnancy in ten ends in a preterm birth, before 37 weeks.
[22] Scientists at the University of California, San Francisco compared blood from 688 women whose babies came early with 1,505 who gave birth on time.[23] Women with early births had more antibodies against their own proteins, and earlier in pregnancy.[22] One attacks IL1RA, the body's own brake on a kind of inflammation that sets off contractions.[22] Injected into pregnant mice, it damaged the placenta.[22] 1 of 10
pregnancies that end before 37 weeks
About one pregnancy in ten ends in a preterm birth. Why it matters — Preterm birth is the leading cause of death in children under five worldwide.
[23] Anakinra, a copy of IL1RA used against arthritis for nearly 20 years, could now be tested, though the antibody turned up in only a fraction of preterm births.[22] -
11
An algorithm picks magnetic brain treatment settings
Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation, or rTMS, treats depression that drugs have not helped by sending magnetic pulses into the brain.
[24] Doctors have no evidence-based guide to its settings at each session.[24] Researchers at Mass General Brigham in Boston trained a learning algorithm on the records of 1,609 patients at 19 groups of clinics.[24] When doctors happened to choose what it would have picked, patients improved by about 0.8 more points at the next session, on a standard depression questionnaire.[24] Why it matters — The study looks back at choices already made, so it shows a link, not proof; the authors project 3.2 extra points if every pick were followed.
[24] Its lead author, Jason Gibbons, has a financial interest in a company making online mental health tests.[24] -
12
Gut bacteria track gut trouble in autistic children
A study in Pediatric Research measured blood and stool markers in 72 autistic children and gut bacteria in 135 children's stools.
[25] Children with stronger autism traits had worse gut symptoms, such as stomach pain and bad-smelling stools.[25] Autistic children had a narrower mix of gut bacteria than other children.[25] But the team found no sign of gut inflammation or a leaky gut wall to explain the symptoms.[25] Why it matters — Between 31% and 84% of autistic children have significant gut symptoms, which can be hard to spot when a child struggles to describe them.
[25] The study measured each child once, so it cannot say which came first.[25]
Why a ward that never closes needs the same doctors for few births as for many
A maternity unit needs doctors ready every night, so a small unit needs almost as many as a big one, for far fewer births.
The twist
A small maternity unit needs the same doctors awake every night as a big one. It just has fewer births to share them across, so a few departures can close it.
The picture
How it works
- A birth can turn into an emergency at any hour
- So a unit needs an obstetrician and a free operating theatre ready day and night
- Covering every hour of the week takes the same team, however many babies arrive
- A small unit has fewer births to share that team, and loses it when a few doctors leave
- More caesareans mean each birth needs the team more often
The same force, elsewhere today
Where this chain is also running, in today's other stories.
-
Daisy Hill and Northern Ireland's rural hospitals
The Southern Trust could not fill its consultant obstetrician posts, so it plans to move every birth to Craigavon from 23 November.
-
New Zealand's election on health
A doctors' union says there are not enough doctors at every level of the roster, and each nurse who leaves for Australia leaves a shift to fill.
-
NHS England's ward rules for trans patients
The rules work only if a free side room is ready when a trans patient arrives, and NHS England's own assessment warns hospitals may not have one.
Where you've seen this
Fire stations
a crew must be on duty overnight whether the town has two fires a month or twenty
Lifeboat stations
a coastal station needs a full crew on call even in the weeks when nobody is in trouble
Small airports
a control tower needs staff for every opening hour, however few planes land
The catch
Merging units makes the night rota easier to fill, but it adds travel time for families, and the evidence Hopkins offers comes from two trusts he ran, in east London and Worcestershire.
And the whole of it
A mother in Barnstaple sees a longer drive, a doctor in Exeter sees more night shifts, and a minister sees a closure to defend. Each is looking at one piece of the same staffing rota, and most people only meet it on the night they need it.
What is really going on
The NHS Alliance, which represents most of England's hospital trusts, is asking ministers to close up to 20 small maternity units, because there are not enough obstetricians to staff them every night and nearly half of births are now caesareans.
Why it works on us — Hopkins calls closing units an act of courage, which casts anyone who objects as afraid of change.
Who gains
-
Bigger maternity units such as Exeter's
— Births and staff move to them when a small unit shuts, as happened after Barnstaple closed.
[5] -
Private hospitals in New Zealand
— New Zealand's government pays them for extra planned operations, which it says added 40,000 surgeries.
[15] -
Politicians in areas with small units
— Keeping units open spares them the backlash that Hopkins says any closure brings, which is why he says bosses fear the taskforce will dodge it.
[1] [3] -
Pregnant and breastfeeding women on NHS wards
— NHS England's own assessment says the single-sex ward rules benefit them.
[14]
Who pays
-
Women in north Devon
— They now travel about 53 miles to Exeter to give birth, and an estimated 194 have done so.
[4] [1] -
Trans patients in English hospitals
— Where no side room is free, they face delays or a ward matching their biological sex, the assessment says.
[14] -
Babies and toddlers in English cities
— More than 120,000 were taken to A&E or hospital with breathing trouble in 2025, in 11 areas.
[17] -
Midwives at Basildon hospital
— Some breathed up to 30 times the legal limit of gas and were not told for 16 months.
[18] -
People in Pahiatua, a small New Zealand town
— Seeing a doctor after hours means a 45-minute drive to the nearest city and up to $245 for an adult.
[15]
What nobody knows yet
Open questions from across today’s stories — ours included.
-
01
Which 20 units Hopkins means.
He gave a number, not a list, and the Health Service Journal's own estimate in August was 24.
[3] -
02
Whether the Barnstaple unit reopens.
It stayed shut after a check this month, and the trust is expected to decide this week.
[4] [1] -
03
How far the trip to Exeter really is.
The BBC has given both 53 and 55 miles, and the Guardian gives 43 miles and a 70-minute drive; none of the reports says how it measured.
[4] [10] [1] -
04
Whether fewer, bigger units are safer.
Hopkins points to two trusts he ran, in east London and Worcestershire, while the obstetricians' college says there are safer answers than closures.
[3] [1] -
05
Whether Daisy Hill stops births on 23 November.
Its trust is planning for it, but Northern Ireland's health minister said in September that no final decision had been made.
[11] [12] -
06
Whether hospitals will have side rooms for trans patients.
NHS England's own assessment says they may not, and NHS England declined to comment.
[14] -
07
Whether the Basildon midwives' symptoms will last.
Staff say they fear for their health in ten years, and no long-term follow-up is described.
[18] -
08
Whether the brain enzyme and the blood pressure drug do anything in people.
The memory enzyme was tested in mice, with only links found in human brains, and losartan switched on brown fat only in mice.
[20] [21]
More than 120 midwives and maternity staff at Basildon University Hospital in Essex will share 735,000 pounds in compensation for breathing leaked gas at work. Their union has written to every NHS trust in England about the risk.
Also true today
- Yeovil hospital's maternity unit in Somerset reopened this year after almost 12 months shut for lack of staff.
- London's ultra-low emission zone, which charges the most polluting vehicles, was followed by bigger and stronger lungs in the city's children.
- In the first weeks after north Devon's unit closed, 54 of its babies were born in Exeter, and none was born before the mother reached the unit.
More from Mind & Body
Across the beats