Day Lila

Space · Thursday, 19 November 2026

Written by AI agents built on Claude, from the sources they cite, and overseen by Zeemish. How it's made

This day: every beat The day in 12 minutes

Swipe 18 stories

A UCL study estimates SpaceX's planned million data-centre satellites could raise launch pollution more than 150-fold

18 stories 29 sources

Signals on this beat

Data centres heading for orbit Building ↑
  • Dcubed, a German parts maker, says such fleets push demand past what suppliers can make. [4]
  • Inflection Space Systems is betting they will need thousands of identical satellites. [5]
  • ALATYR, a French firm, is planning its own. [6]
Too few big US rockets High ↑
  • ULA's Vulcan rocket is grounded again with no date to fly. [12]
  • Blue Origin's New Glenn, grounded since a May explosion, could fly again as soon as January. [11]
Europe building its own Building ↑
  • CUBECOM, a South African radio maker, says European buyers want parts made in Europe. [21]
  • The head of Germany's space agency wants Europe to build a new heavy rocket. [26]
Fights over who decides Building ↑
  • Elon Musk said decisions to use satellite internet for strikes belong to the US government, not him. [15]
  • Senate Republicans advanced an FCC nominee while every Democrat stayed away. [7]

The stories

18 on this beat today.

Each story is told in its parts: what happened, the questions that explain it, how it works, who gains and who pays, and the good news. A part appears when the sources give it.

  1. 01

    A UCL study estimates SpaceX's planned million data-centre satellites could raise launch pollution more than 150-fold

    150 times

    the emissions of 2025's launches, which the plan's launches could give off

    it would take at least 5,000 launches a year [1]

    1 million

    data-centre satellites SpaceX has asked the FCC to allow

    SpaceX's Starlink fleet is about 11,000 strong now [2]

    233,000 to 507,000 tonnes

    of nitrogen oxides a year, the study's range for the plan

    like the yearly emissions of some European countries [1]

    What happened

    • Two researchers at University College London estimate the pollution from SpaceX's plan for 1 million satellites. [1]
    • The satellites would be data centres, the computers that run AI, placed in orbit. [1]
    • SpaceX asked the US Federal Communications Commission, the FCC, to allow 1 million of them in January 2026. [1]
    • The authors assumed SpaceX would use Starship Block 4, a rocket meant to lift at least 200 tonnes. [1]
    • Lifting the plan would take at least 5,000 launches a year, around 14 every day. [1]
    • In 2025 the whole world made only about 330 orbital launches. [1]
    • Elon Musk, who runs SpaceX, has said it aims for 10,000 Starship launches a year by 2030. [2]
    • A craft falling back from orbit heats the air so much that nitrogen and oxygen join into nitrogen oxides. [1]
    • Nitrogen oxides can set off reactions that destroy ozone. [1] Ozone high in the air blocks harmful ultraviolet light. [1]
    • It could mean 70 to 150 times more nitrogen oxides from spacecraft returning to Earth. [1]
    • SpaceX plans to move 80% of its old satellites into higher orbits where dead craft are parked. [1]
    • If the rest burn up, about 200,000 tonnes of spacecraft would turn to vapour high in the air each year. [1]
    • That is more than 200 times the amount from satellites and other objects in 2024. [1]
    • Burning metals such as aluminium leave tiny particles that can speed up the reactions that destroy ozone. [1]
    • Meteors, bits of space rock burning up in the air, already make some nitrogen oxides every year. [1]
    • The plan's nitrogen oxides could be at least 6 times what meteors make each year, the study says. [1]
    • Starship burns methane, so it makes less soot than SpaceX's Falcon 9, which burns kerosene. [1]
    • But if SpaceX keeps venting unused methane, about 60,000 tonnes could escape each year. [1] Methane warms the planet far more than carbon dioxide. [1]

    Who is involved

    ALATYR, a French company, is developing data centres for orbit. [6] This week it agreed to explore using solar cells from Flexell Space, a German firm. [6]

    Dcubed, a German maker of satellite parts, says demand is booming. [4] Fleets that need lots of power, orbital data centres among them, drive it. [4]

    • Eloise Marais and Connor Barker researchers at University College London in the UK; they wrote the estimate
    • ALATYR
    • Flexell Space
    • SpaceX Elon Musk's rocket company; it asked to launch 1 million data-centre satellites
    • The FCC the US agency that licenses satellites; in September it exempted fleet filings from environmental review
    • Aaron Boley a University of British Columbia scientist who studies space's effect on the environment; not part of the study

    How it unfolded

    1. Jan 2026 SpaceX asks the FCC to allow 1 million data-centre satellites [1]
    2. Sep 2026 the FCC exempts fleet filings from environmental review [1]
    3. 18 Nov the UCL estimate of the plan's pollution is reported [1]

    Why it matters

    Pollution high in the air can linger for years, unlike pollution from cars and factories, so its effects build up. [1]

    A thinner ozone layer means less protection from harmful ultraviolet light. [1]

    The particles could also form high hazes that change how much sunlight reaches the ground. [1]

    Think it through

    1. 1

      Why can't they give one exact figure?

      SpaceX has not said what the data-centre satellites are made of. [1] So the team could not work out the metal pollution at all. [1]

    2. 2

      So where did their numbers come from?

      Without official figures, they used Wikipedia, space fans' forums and a launch catalogue kept by astrophysicist Jonathan McDowell. [1]

    3. 3

      Who is meant to check a plan like this?

      The FCC licenses satellite fleets. [1] In September it exempted fleet filings from environmental review. [1]

    4. 4

      Doesn't anyone check the rocket launches?

      The FAA, the US aviation regulator, can still demand environmental checks on launches. [1] Those checks need not count what a whole fleet does over its life. [1]

    5. 5

      What would the researchers need from SpaceX?

      They ask firms to publish fuel types, materials, returning mass and re-entry speeds. [1] Barker says even a rough share of aluminium or titanium would help. [1]

    6. 6

      Who runs the FCC from here?

      On Wednesday a Senate committee advanced a nominee who would be the 3rd Republican of the FCC's 5 commissioners. [7]

      3 of 5

      FCC seats Republicans would hold

    7. 7

      So who can make SpaceX say what is inside?

      The FCC holds the licence SpaceX wants, and it may never require an environmental check. [1] SpaceX holds the facts the scientists say they need. [1]

    How it works

    People who study regulation call this a regulatory gap: a harm that falls between the rules of two agencies.

    The FAA checks one launch at a time, and the FCC waived review of fleets. [1] So in this regulatory gap, nobody weighs what all the launches do to the air. [1]

    Seen it before

    In a shared flat each person washes their own plate, and nobody is in charge of the kitchen floor.

    The truth

    • What is really going on SpaceX's million-satellite plan, Dcubed's booming orders and Inflection's bulk factory are all bets on data centres in orbit. [1][4][5]The estimate of what SpaceX's plan does to the upper air came from two UCL researchers working from public guesses, because SpaceX disclosed little. [1]
    • Why it works on people A giant rocket caught by its launch tower was watched by millions, while gas left high in the air cannot be seen at all. [1]
    • The figures rest on assumptions about rockets and satellites SpaceX has not described in public. [1] Marais says the team has nearly reached the limit of what public facts allow. [1]
    • The study is a preprint, so other scientists have not yet checked it. [1]
    • Nobody knows yet

      When the FCC will rule on SpaceX's request for 1 million satellites.

      The FCC needs 3 commissioners to do business, and who fills its seats is being fought over in the US Senate. [7]

    • Nobody knows yet

      How much methane Starship would leak in everyday use.

      The 60,000-tonne estimate assumes SpaceX keeps venting methane the way it has on test flights. [1]

    What comes next

    The paper is waiting for review at Earth and Space Chemistry, a journal of the American Chemical Society. [1]

  1. 02

    A giant star swallows its partner

    What happened

    • For the first time, astronomers have watched a giant star swallow its smaller partner star. [9] They reported it in the journal Nature on 18 November. [8]
    • The pair is in the Andromeda galaxy, about 2.5 million light-years away. [8]
    • Late in 2025 it flashed 100 times brighter, as the smaller star was torn apart at the giant's core. [9]
    • The James Webb Space Telescope looked at it just 47 days after the outburst. [8]

    Who is involved

    The giant is about 7 times the Sun's mass and 350 times its width. [8]

    How it unfolded

    From 2018 the star slowly brightened, which the team puts down to the partner spiralling in and heating it. [8]

    1. 2018 slow brightening begins
    2. Late 2025 a huge outburst

    Why it matters

    Nearly a third of stars go through this stage at some point, says astronomer Jason Nordhaus. [9]

    Think it through

    1. 1

      Why had nobody seen one before?

      The stage lasts only a few years of a star's billions, so it is easy to miss. [9]

    2. 2

      What did it show that experts got wrong?

      Heat from the swallowed star rose by convection, the churning of hot gas. [9] Experts had thought convection would not matter. [9]

    3. 3

      So how many more will be found?

      New sky surveys by the Vera Rubin Observatory and the Roman Space Telescope should find many more, Karambelkar says. [8]

    How it works

    Astrophysicists call this the common envelope phase: two stars orbiting inside one shared cloud of gas. [10]

    In this common envelope, the partner, about 70% of the Sun's mass, was slowed by drag and spiralled in. [10]

    Seen it before

    A spoon dropped into thick honey slows and sinks, because the honey drags on it.

    The truth

    • Lead author Viraj Karambelkar says both stars may instead have survived in a much tighter orbit. [8] More watching is needed to settle it. [8]

    Good news

    • For the first time, astronomers watched a giant star in the Andromeda galaxy swallow its partner, a stage of star life predicted for decades and never seen.
  2. 03

    Vulcan's engines were starved of fuel

    What happened

    • ULA says early data point to too little fuel reaching the engines of its Vulcan rocket's first stage. [12]
    • On 18 November ULA said the fault seems to lie in how the rocket fed its BE-4 engines. [13]
    • The 6 side boosters, whose nozzles failed on 2 earlier flights, worked normally this time. [12]

    Who is involved

    ULA, the United Launch Alliance, is a company owned half each by Boeing and Lockheed Martin. [13]

    • ULA

    How it unfolded

    Vulcan failed on 15 November and lost 40 Amazon Leo internet satellites. [13] It was ULA's first total failure in 20 years. [13]

    Why it matters

    The BE-4 engine also powers New Glenn, the big rocket of Blue Origin, which exploded on its pad in May. [12]

    With the engine cleared, Blue Origin can aim to fly New Glenn again as soon as January. [11]

    Think it through

    1. 1

      Who is left waiting on Vulcan?

      The US Space Force is waiting, and so is Amazon, which bought 38 Vulcan launches for its Leo network. [12]

      38Vulcan launches Amazon bought

    2. 2

      So who carries Amazon's satellites meanwhile?

      With Vulcan and New Glenn grounded, Amazon's other booked rides are on Ariane 6 and SpaceX's Falcon 9. [12]

    3. 3

      Can't SpaceX's Starship fill the gap?

      Starship's launches may mostly carry SpaceX's own cargo: Starlink satellites and its planned orbital data centres. [3]

    4. 4

      So who decides when Vulcan flies again?

      ULA leads the investigation, but the FAA, the US aviation regulator, must approve its final report and fixes. [14]

    How it works

    Rocket engineers call the tanks, pipes and valves that deliver fuel to an engine its propellant feed system.

    Vulcan's propellant feed system failed to supply enough fuel, so the booster made too little thrust though the engines worked. [11]

    Seen it before

    A car with a blocked fuel line splutters, even when its engine is perfectly fine.

    The truth

    • ULA has not said which part failed to deliver fuel, or why. [12] Ars Technica expects Vulcan to be grounded for several months. [11]
    • Nobody knows yet

      Whether New Glenn really flies again in January.

      Blue Origin's own filing to the FCC covers a window from 15 January to 15 April. [12]

    Good news

    • The finding is a major relief for Blue Origin, and for NASA, which counts on New Glenn for Moon missions. [11]
  1. 04

    Musk says Zelenskyy is lying

    What happened

    • Elon Musk, who runs SpaceX, said Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelenskyy is lying about limits on SpaceX's Starshield service. [15]
    • He spoke on 18 November at the New York Times DealBook Summit, by video call from China. [16]
    • Musk now says Zelenskyy wants to use Starlink, the civilian service, for attacks. [15]

    Who is involved

    Starlink is SpaceX's satellite internet service, and Starshield is its military version. [17]

    How it unfolded

    On 12 November Zelenskyy said Starshield again cut out on Ukrainian drones above 161 kilometres an hour, over occupied land. [17]

    SpaceX told Ars Technica then that there had been no change. [17]

    Why it matters

    Ukrainian officials reportedly believe the limit was brought back to put pressure on Ukraine in peace talks with Russia. [17]

    Think it through

    1. 1

      So who actually decides the limits?

      Musk says Starshield is controlled by the US government. [15] He says the kill decision is the US War Department's, not his. [15]

    2. 2

      Has anyone checked who ordered them?

      The US defence department's inspector general, its internal watchdog, declined a request from US senators to investigate. [17]

    3. 3

      So who holds the power over the link?

      The US Pentagon pays SpaceX to give Ukraine Starshield. [17] Musk says the US government, not SpaceX, decides how it is used. [15]

    How it works

    Military planners call a tool built for ordinary customers that armies can also use dual-use.

    Musk draws the dual-use line himself: Starlink is a civilian system, and strikes need Starshield. [15]

    Seen it before

    A kitchen knife is sold for cooking, but the shop cannot control what a buyer does with it.

    Why a harm can fall between two regulators

    When one agency checks each launch and another licenses whole fleets, the harm that comes from adding them up can be checked by neither.

    The twist

    A plan can pass every agency's check and still have nobody checking its biggest risk.

    The picture

    Each agency's check covers its own piece. The pollution comes from all the launches and satellites added together, and neither check covers that.

    Step by step

    1. One activity touches two agencies' rules
    2. Each agency checks only its own piece
    3. The harm comes from all the pieces added up
    4. Neither agency's review covers the sum
    5. Outsiders end up estimating it with guesses

    The same force, elsewhere today

    Where this chain is also running, in today's other stories.

    • Musk and Zelenskyy's Starshield row

      Musk says the US government decides Starshield's use, SpaceX says nothing changed, and the US Pentagon's watchdog declined to ask who ordered the limits.

    Seen it before

    Rivers that cross borders

    each country rules its own stretch, so harm that builds up downstream can be nobody's to stop

    Food safety

    when one agency inspects farms and another inspects factories, a risk that starts in one and shows in the other is easy to miss

    Banking before 2008

    lenders that were not quite banks fell outside most banking rules, and their risks were added up too late

    The catch

    Splitting the job is not a mistake in itself: each agency knows its own piece well, and a joint review can be slow and costly.

    And the whole of it

    The FAA, the FCC, SpaceX and the two researchers are each doing the job they were handed. The upper air sits above all of them, and above the rest of us too.

    The truth

    • Zelenskyy says the US gave very little information about the limit, and SpaceX denies any change. [17]
  1. 05

    FCC and NASA nominees pass without Democrats

    What happened

    • A US Senate committee approved 3 nominees for NASA and the FCC on 18 November, though no Democrat attended. [7]
    • Every vote was 15 to 0, with all 15 Republicans present. [7]

    Who is involved

    Joshua Shoemaker would be NASA's chief financial officer. [7] Robert Steinau would be its inspector general, the agency's watchdog. [7]

    Danielle Thumann Severs, a senior lawyer for FCC chairman Brendan Carr, would join the FCC itself. [7]

    • Joshua Shoemaker NASA's money chief
    • Robert Steinau NASA's watchdog
    • Danielle Thumann Severs nominee to the FCC

    Why it matters

    The FCC hands out the radio frequencies every satellite needs, and sets the rules on space junk. [7]

    Think it through

    1. 1

      Why did the Democrats stay away?

      Thumann Severs is not paired with a Democratic nominee, breaking a long-standing practice. [7]

    2. 2

      What are the Democrats afraid of?

      They fear Trump will fire Anna Gomez, the FCC's only Democrat, once Republicans hold 3 of its 5 seats. [7] A US Supreme Court ruling in June allows that. [7]

      3 of 5

      FCC seats Republicans would hold

    3. 3

      So who holds the committee next?

      Democrats take control of the committee in January, when Maria Cantwell is expected to chair it again. [7]

    How it works

    Political scientists call a quorum the smallest number of members who must attend before a body can act.

    This committee's quorum needs one minority member. [7] Chairman Ted Cruz still declared the nominations approved. [7]

    Seen it before

    A club vote only counts when enough members turn up, so staying away can block it.

    The truth

    • Before this, a meeting with no minority member could not take votes at all. [7] Shoemaker has no clear space background, SpacePolicyOnline notes. [7]
  2. 06

    Mars helicopters ride a nuclear spacecraft

    What happened

    • NASA plans to fly 3 small helicopters to Mars on SR-1 Freedom, a spacecraft driven by a nuclear reactor. [18]
    • SR-1 Freedom is due to launch in late 2028 and drop the helicopters at Mars in autumn 2030. [18]
    • Their main tool is a radar that can look under the ground for buried rock and ice. [18]

    How it unfolded

    The helicopter project, called SkyFall, started in March 2026 and has grown from about 6 people to over 200. [18]

    1. Late 2028 launch
    2. Autumn 2030 helicopters dropped at Mars

    Why it matters

    Ice under the ground could give future crews water and fuel, says project scientist Matthew Golombek. [18]

    Scott Hubbard, NASA's first Mars programme director, calls the pairing a bit of a shotgun marriage. [18]

    Think it through

    1. 1

      Why is that a problem?

      Usually science goals come first, but here scientists must fit goals to a craft already chosen, Hubbard says. [18]

    2. 2

      Does the nuclear engine get there faster?

      No, Hubbard says: this nuclear electric engine shaves no time off the trip to Mars. [18]

    3. 3

      So who gains from tying them together?

      Hubbard calls it a tech demo piggybacking on another mission, as an opening bid for a nuclear NASA. [18]

    How it works

    Spaceflight planners call the short spell when Earth and Mars line up for the cheapest trip a launch window.

    SR-1 may not be ready for the 2028 launch window, Hubbard says. [18] NASA has an ordinary launch plan in reserve, he adds. [18]

    Seen it before

    A school trip leaves on a set day, and anyone not ready waits for the next trip.

    The truth

    • Golombek calls it the shortest Mars mission ever conceived, and the helicopters' science routes are not yet planned. [18]
  3. 07

    US tests a 56-year-old nuclear missile

    What happened

    • The US Air Force test-fired an unarmed Minuteman III nuclear missile from California late on 17 November. [19]
    • It was the first such test in 6 months, and the third of 2026. [19]
    • Test missiles usually fly 4,200 miles to targets at Kwajalein Atoll in the Marshall Islands. [19]
    • The Air Force said the test was scheduled years ago and was not a reply to world events. [19]

    How it unfolded

    1. March first test of 2026
    2. May second test
    3. 17 November third test

    Why it matters

    It came as President Trump travelled to China to meet Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin. [19]

    Think it through

    1. 1

      Why keep testing a missile this old?

      The Minuteman III is 56 years old. [19] Its replacement, Sentinel, starts arriving only in the early 2030s. [19]

    2. 2

      How much is the Air Force spending to keep it?

      The Air Force's 2027 budget asks for nearly $86.5 billion for Minuteman upgrades and research. [19]

      $86.5 billionasked for Minuteman upgrades and research

    3. 3

      So what is the test meant to show?

      The Air Force says the tests keep the Minuteman effective and reliable as a nuclear deterrent. [19]

    How it works

    Strategists call it deterrence: a threat of harm strong enough that a rival decides not to attack.

    Deterrence needs rivals to believe the weapon works, so each test shows the 56-year-old missile still flies. [19]

    Seen it before

    A guard dog keeps burglars away only if they believe it will bite.

    The truth

    • Officials gave no details of this flight, so the 4,200-mile route is only what such tests usually fly. [19]
  4. 08

    Simons Observatory starts mapping the first light

    What happened

    • The Simons Observatory, 4 telescopes in the Atacama Desert, has started surveying the oldest light in the universe. [20]
    • That light, the cosmic microwave background, was set free about 380,000 years after the Big Bang. [20]
    • Together they carry almost 98,000 detectors, 16 times more than the Atacama Cosmology Telescope, an earlier one. [20]

    Who is involved

    It has 3 small telescopes and 1 large one, 6 metres across. [20]

    How it unfolded

    It spent 2 years setting up its instruments before starting work. [20]

    Why it matters

    It hunts for a twisted pattern in that light, left by ripples in space from the universe's first instant. [20]

    Think it through

    1. 1

      Didn't another telescope already see that pattern?

      The South Pole Telescope saw it, but gravity bending light can make the same pattern, so doubt remained. [20]

    2. 2

      How much better is this one?

      A few months of its maps are already deeper than years of maps from Planck, a European satellite. [20]

    How it works

    Astronomers call it gravitational lensing when mass between us and a light source bends the light on its way.

    Lensing can fake the twisted pattern. [20] Maps of lenses made at the South Pole Telescope's site will help remove it. [20]

    Seen it before

    To hear a quiet voice in a noisy room, you first learn the noise and tune it out.

    The truth

    • Finding the pattern will take years of watching, so no answer on the first instant is due soon. [20]

    Good news

    • The Simons Observatory's first few months of maps of the universe's oldest light are already deeper than years of maps from the Planck satellite.
  5. 09

    Dcubed raises money to make more satellite parts

    What happened

    • Dcubed, a German maker of satellite parts, raised 27.2 million euros to grow its factories. [4]
    • It makes moving parts and solar panels for satellites. [4]
    • The money will pay for a new plant in Colorado and a bigger one in Germany. [4] Dcubed aims to make 4 times as many parts. [4]

    How it unfolded

    In the past year it more than doubled both its production and its revenue. [4]

    Why it matters

    Satellite makers are short of parts, and boss Thomas Sinn says nobody really knows who should produce them all. [4]

    Think it through

    1. 1

      Why is demand so high now?

      Planned fleets that need a lot of power, orbital data centres among them, are driving it. [4]

    2. 2

      Who is putting the money in?

      Warsaw Equity Group led the round. [4] Dcubed hopes a US investor joins too, to help it sell to the US military. [4]

    How it works

    Economists call it a supply bottleneck when one stage of making something cannot keep up with demand.

    In this bottleneck, Sinn says, demand for satellite power is more than all suppliers can make, so the fastest wins. [4]

    Seen it before

    When one bakery in town bakes fastest, the queue forms at its door.

    The truth

    • Dcubed says its new HALO solar panel could cut the cost of power 10 to 100 times. [4] It has not flown: its first test is due in mid-2027. [4]
  6. 10

    Start-up plans satellites in bulk

    What happened

    • Inflection Space Systems, a start-up, has booked its first mission, a 36-kilogram test satellite called Pax. [5]
    • Pax will fly no earlier than 2028, sharing a rocket booked through Exolaunch, a firm that sells such rides. [5]
    • It will test the parts of Exponent, a standard satellite body Inflection wants to build by the thousands. [5]
    • Buying 1 Exponent would cost $1.5 million, falling to $700,000 each for orders of 100 or more. [5]

    Why it matters

    Most satellite makers build a handful of each design for one customer, says Inflection's boss, Alex Lisso. [5]

    Think it through

    1. 1

      Who would buy thousands?

      Lisso is betting on fleets for orbital data centres and communications, which would need more satellites than ever made. [5]

    2. 2

      How can it make them so cheaply?

      Its factory is designed to assemble satellites by machine, around the clock, with the lights off. [5]

    How it works

    Factory managers call most satellite making high-mix, low-volume: many designs, each made a few at a time. [5]

    Inflection wants low-mix, high-volume instead: one design made in bulk, so each one costs less. [5]

    Seen it before

    A bakery making only one kind of loaf can bake far more than a shop icing custom cakes.

    The truth

    • Exponent is still a design: the first one is due by the end of 2027. [5]
  7. 11

    African radio maker opens a Dutch office

    What happened

    • CUBECOM, a South African maker of satellite radios, is opening an office in Delft, in the Netherlands. [21]
    • European buyers bring in over half its yearly revenue. [21] It sold them more than 300 parts in 2026. [21]
    • That helped it triple its revenue compared with last year. [21]
    • It aims for 30 million euros in revenue by 2030 or 2031, 6 times what it makes now. [21]

    Why it matters

    European countries want their own space abilities, says its boss, Sampie Booysen. [21]

    Think it through

    1. 1

      Why open an office rather than just ship parts?

      European buyers want parts made in Europe, so the Delft office aims to stop CUBECOM losing deals to distance. [21]

    2. 2

      What has changed for its buyers?

      Orders that were 2 or 3 units now run to tens or twenties, Booysen says. [21]

    How it works

    Governments call it sovereign capability: being able to build key things without relying on another country. [21]

    To fit that sovereign capability, CUBECOM plans European engineers and a factory in Europe within 5 years. [21]

    Seen it before

    A school picks players from its own pupils first, even when a better one lives next door.

    The truth

    • Its growth chief, Mariechen Du Plessis, says Europe is harder to sell to because it is so political. [21] Much of the revenue goal rests on winning there. [21]
  8. 12

    Indian start-up plans a heat-mapping fleet

    What happened

    • SatLeo Labs, an Indian start-up, plans 15 small satellites to measure the heat coming off Earth's surface. [22]
    • The fleet, called Pyro, would map heat in detail finer than 10 metres, enough to show single streets. [22]
    • The firm has raised about $6 million and holds letters of intent worth $54 million from possible customers. [22]

    How it unfolded

    Its first test camera, TAPAS-1, reached orbit on a SpaceX rocket on 1 October. [22]

    Why it matters

    Heat maps can show crops short of water days before their leaves wilt, research suggests. [22]

    Think it through

    1. 1

      Why build their own satellites?

      Its founders found heat data from Landsat, a US government satellite, too coarse for India's small farms. [22]

    2. 2

      Who else does this?

      Only a few private firms, such as SatVu in the UK and OroraTech in Germany, run heat-imaging satellites. [22]

    How it works

    Physicists call this thermal infrared imaging: warm things give off invisible infrared light, and hotter things give off more.

    SatLeo's thermal infrared camera reads 2 bands of infrared, so one design can serve both farms and the military. [22]

    Seen it before

    A hand held near a stove feels its heat before any glow can be seen.

    The truth

    • The 15-satellite fleet is a plan for early 2030. [22] So far one test camera is in orbit. [22]
  9. 13

    Space dust shows heavy water beyond Neptune

    What happened

    • Scientists at NASA's Johnson Space Center and UCLA studied 12 specks of dust from beyond Neptune. [23]
    • They say the region once held a store of heavy water that never mixed with the inner planets. [23]
    • Scars from solar radiation showed the grains came from the Kuiper Belt, the icy zone past Neptune. [23]

    Who is involved

    Most oxygen is oxygen-16. [23] Here heavy means water made with the heavier oxygen-17 and oxygen-18. [23]

    How it unfolded

    A high-flying NASA plane caught the grains, in a programme collecting space dust since 1981. [23]

    Why it matters

    It backs a long-held idea of how sunlight sorted oxygen atoms when the planets were forming. [23]

    Think it through

    1. 1

      Why didn't that water reach Earth?

      The authors say Saturn's gravity made a barrier in the young disc of gas and dust. [23]

    2. 2

      Why couldn't comet missions settle it?

      Rosetta and Stardust collected comet material, but catching it melted the samples and wiped the oxygen record. [23]

    How it works

    Chemists call versions of one element that differ in weight isotopes.

    The grains held far more of the heavy oxygen isotopes than the Sun, so their water formed far out. [23]

    Seen it before

    Sand from two beaches looks the same, but a close look at the grains shows which beach it came from.

    The truth

    • The finding rests on 12 grains, worked back through chemical models to the water they once held. [23]
  10. 14

    Are Uranus and Neptune hiding rock?

    What happened

    • A new paper asks whether Uranus and Neptune hide large amounts of rock under their thick air. [24]
    • The test would be argon-40, a gas made when radioactive potassium in rock breaks down. [24]
    • On Earth argon-40 makes up around 1% of the air. [24]

    Who is involved

    Olivier Mousis of the Southwest Research Institute led it, in The Planetary Science Journal. [24]

    • Olivier Mousis led the paper

    Why it matters

    The two planets are called ice giants, so finding rock would change what they are thought to be. [24]

    Think it through

    1. 1

      Couldn't the argon come from somewhere else?

      Yes: the planets may have swallowed argon-40 left in the cloud the Sun formed from. [24]

    2. 2

      So how would anyone tell them apart?

      A probe would also measure argon-36, which rock does not make, to estimate the argon they were born with. [24]

    How it works

    Scientists call a measurement that stands in for one they cannot make a proxy. [24]

    Nobody can drill into Uranus, so argon-40 in its air is the proxy for rock below. [24]

    Seen it before

    Smoke from a chimney shows a fire is burning inside, though you cannot see the fire.

    The truth

    • The answer depends on where the two planets formed, which scientists still argue about. [24]
  11. 15

    Fermi maps 450 gamma-ray sources

    What happened

    • Scientists using the Fermi gamma-ray space telescope listed 450 sources of low-energy gamma rays. [25] It is the clearest view yet of this range. [25]
    • They combined 14 years of the telescope's data with statistical models to pin the sources down. [25]
    • Of the 450, 325 lie far outside our galaxy and 52 inside it. [25]

    Who is involved

    Gamma rays are the most energetic kind of light. [25]

    Why it matters

    About 60 look like brand new discoveries, which other telescopes can now follow up. [25]

    Think it through

    1. 1

      Why was this range so hard to see?

      At these energies Fermi can trace a single gamma ray only to a patch of sky 20 degrees wide. [25]

      20 degreesthe blur on a single gamma ray

    2. 2

      What are most of the sources?

      Almost half are a type of blazar: a giant black hole with a jet pointed straight at Earth. [25]

    How it works

    Astronomers call the hard-to-see band between X-rays and high-energy gamma rays the MeV gap. [25]

    Each gamma ray in the MeV gap is a blur, so 14 years of them were stacked. [25]

    Seen it before

    One shaky photo of a bird is useless, but many together show where it really sits.

    The truth

    • Some of the new sources may be signals from two nearby objects overlapping, the report says. [25]

    Good news

    • Fourteen years of Fermi telescope data turned up about 60 gamma-ray sources that look like new discoveries.
  12. 16

    Germany's space chief wants a European heavy rocket

    What happened

    • Walther Pelzer, head of DLR, Germany's aerospace centre, wants Europe to build a new heavy rocket. [26]
    • He spoke at the Space Tech Expo Europe gathering in Bremen, Germany. [26]
    • Germany could also try launching from a ship next year, using a small research rocket. [26]

    How it unfolded

    Europe now has just 1 heavy rocket, Ariane 6. [26]

    Why it matters

    A launch site at sea could be placed near the equator, with rockets shipped out to it, Pelzer said. [26]

    Think it through

    1. 1

      Why isn't Europe's current plan enough?

      ESA has paid several firms to build small rockets and grow them bigger, which Pelzer says is not enough. [26]

    2. 2

      Which sites would count as European?

      Pelzer said the EU should count UK and Norwegian launch sites as European, though neither country is in the EU. [26]

    How it works

    Engineers call a system resilient when it keeps working after one part is lost.

    Pelzer said an offshore launch site would add resilience, as well as the launches Europe urgently needs. [26]

    Seen it before

    A family with two cars still gets to work when one breaks down.

    The truth

    • Some European firms fear Germany is turning away from working with them on space security. [26] Pelzer tried to calm them. [26]
    • Nobody knows yet

      Whether Europe's governments will pay for a new heavy rocket.

      Pelzer named no cost and no date, and ESA has so far paid for small rockets meant to grow. [26]

  13. 17

    Europe may build more Orion modules

    What happened

    • ESA, Europe's space agency, is in talks to order 2 more service modules for Orion, NASA's crew capsule. [27]
    • 2 have flown, 2 more are in the US, and another 2 are being built. [27]

    Who is involved

    The module, built by Airbus, powers Orion and gives its crew air, water and the right temperature. [27]

    Why it matters

    It is Europe's flagship part in Artemis, NASA's Moon programme, and survived NASA's change of plans this year. [27]

    Think it through

    1. 1

      What did Europe lose in that change?

      NASA's change of plans ended Gateway, a Moon programme that had European parts in it. [27]

    2. 2

      So what does Europe want from NASA now?

      Pelzer of DLR says Europe should only join partnerships where its part is indispensable, on equal terms. [27]

    How it works

    Economists call it bargaining power: the side that is hardest to replace gets better terms.

    The module keeps Orion's crew alive, and that is the bargaining power Pelzer wants Europe to keep in Artemis. [27]

    Seen it before

    The only player who brought a football gets a say in what game is played.

    The truth

    • The 2 extra modules are so far only under discussion, says Jan-Henrik Horstmann, who runs the programme at ESA. [27]
  14. 18

    Countries build their own way round Starlink

    What happened

    • Ukraine hit the Crimean Bridge on 17 November without Starlink or Starshield, an officer involved told The Times. [29]
    • Instead, drones passed video signals on to the missiles, so they could hit exact points on the bridge. [29]
    • Semafor, citing the Financial Times, says the drones worked as a network of flying modems. [28]
    • In India, billionaire Mukesh Ambani is seeking factory partners for an Indian-controlled rival to Starlink, Bloomberg reports. [28]

    Who is involved

    Starlink is SpaceX's satellite internet service, and Starshield is its military version. [29]

    • Mukesh Ambani Indian billionaire, wants a home-grown rival

    How it unfolded

    On 12 November Zelenskyy reported big disruptions to Starshield along the whole front line. [29] Starlink blamed technical problems. [29]

    1. 12 November Starshield disruptions reported
    2. 17 November bridge hit without it

    Why it matters

    More countries are speeding up work on rivals to Starlink, Semafor says. [28] SpaceX and the US government traded blame for the slowdown. [28]

    Think it through

    1. 1

      Why would Ukraine say this so publicly?

      The officer said the strike was timed before Trump met Putin and Xi, to show Putin is weak. [29]

    2. 2

      Why build a rival instead of buying Starlink?

      Ambani's push comes during a running dispute between Musk and India's government, Semafor says. [28]

    3. 3

      So what does Ukraine think it has shown?

      The officer said the Americans tried to cut Ukraine's links, and this strike showed it can manage without Starlink. [29]

    How it works

    Radio engineers call it a relay network: each link receives a signal and passes it on to the next.

    In Ukraine's relay network, drones carried the video signal to the missiles instead of satellites. [29]

    Seen it before

    A note passed along a row of desks reaches the back of the class without a postman.

    The truth

    • The strike account comes from one unnamed officer involved, quoted by The Times. [29] Ambani's plan rests on Bloomberg's report, and no figures are given. [28]

Across the beats