Day Lila

14-minute course

Course · Start

Money · 14-minute course

Is Social Security a Ponzi scheme?

A US senator called it "a legal Ponzi scheme" on 18 November, and its retirement fund is projected to run out in 2032. This is how a pension paid by today's workers works, and what happens when it runs short.

Made from the news of Friday, 20 November 2026.

Swipe up to start ↑Scroll down to start ↓

What makes a Ponzi scheme a Ponzi scheme?

Swipe up to start ↑Scroll down to start ↓

In the news · 20 Nov 2026

“a legal Ponzi scheme”
Ron Johnson, US senator

On Wednesday 18 November, Ron Johnson, a US senator who chairs the Senate's budget committee, called Social Security "a legal Ponzi scheme".

See the story →

In the news · 20 Nov 2026

Social Security is the US state pension: money the government pays people when they retire. It is paid to more than 71 million people, most of them retired.

See the story →

In the news · 20 Nov 2026

A Ponzi scheme is a fraud. It pays earlier investors with newer investors' money, and tells them it is profit. That is how the US markets regulator describes it.

See the story →

In the news · 20 Nov 2026

Johnson says Social Security fits that description, apart from the fraud. The same day, he called his words on TV about shutting it down "imprecise".

See the story →

Seen it before · 1920

The name comes from Charles Ponzi. In Boston in 1920, he promised investors a 50% profit in 45 days.

He said the profit came from buying postage vouchers cheaply abroad and cashing them in the US. In fact, he paid earlier investors with newer investors' money.

To keep paying, a scheme like this needs more new money every month than the month before. When new money slows, the cash runs out.

Ponzi's scheme fell apart in August 1920. His investors got back less than 30 cents for each dollar they had put in.

Seen it before · 2008

Bernie Madoff ran the biggest one known. He was arrested on 11 December 2008, when clients asked for about $7 billion back and he did not have it.

The idea

So a Ponzi scheme has three marks. It hides where the money comes from, it needs new money to keep growing, and when that stops almost nothing is left.

Quick check

A club pays members 20% a year and says it comes from trading. It shows no trades, and its payouts grow only when many new members join. What would make it a Ponzi scheme?

Tap the answer you think is right.

Tap any other answer to see why.

Today's workers pay today's retirees

Swipe up to start ↑Scroll down to start ↓

In the news · 20 Nov 2026

Social Security works on a plan called pay-as-you-go: money coming in this year pays the people collecting this year.

See the story →
a tax on every pay packet

The money comes from a payroll tax, a tax taken out of wages each pay day. By law, most US workers must pay it.

In the news · 20 Nov 2026

Workers and employers each pay 6.2% of wages, on pay up to $192,300 in 2027.

See the story →

Seen it before · 1940

Ida May Fuller got the first monthly Social Security check, dated 31 January 1940. It was for $22.54. She had paid in $24.75 in taxes in all.

She lived to 100 and collected $22,888.92 over her retirement.

Her pension came from the people working at the time. The first retirees had paid in for only a few years, yet were paid for life.

In the news · 20 Nov 2026

It still works that way. A worker on the median wage, the middle wage, retiring in 2027 can expect about $730,000, after paying under $200,000 in taxes. Today's workers' taxes cover the gap.

See the story →

Same, and different

So, like a Ponzi scheme, it pays older members with newer members' money. Unlike one, nothing is hidden: the law that sets the tax and the payments is public.

And it does not need ever more new members. It needs the number of workers for each retiree to hold steady. When that number falls, the money runs short.

The fund

In years when the tax brought in more than was paid out, the extra was lent to the US government. The fund holds those loans as Treasury bonds, the government's written promises to repay.

In the news · 20 Nov 2026

Johnson says workers' money was already spent. Experts say the fund's Treasury bonds are real debts the government owes it.

See the story →

Quick check

Maria starts her first job this year and pays the Social Security tax. Where does her money go?

Tap the answer you think is right.

Tap any other answer to see why.

Why the money is running short

Swipe up to start ↑Scroll down to start ↓

The number

workers for each person collecting

A pay-as-you-go pension rests on one number: how many workers pay in for each person collecting.

In the news · 20 Nov 2026

Fewer workers now pay for each person collecting

In 1950 more than 16 workers paid in for each person collecting. By 1960 it was about 5.

See the story →

In the news · 20 Nov 2026

The early drop came as more retirees qualified for a pension. Today there are about 2.7, and officials expect about 2 within a couple of decades.

See the story →

Since 1960 it has kept falling, for four reasons. People live longer, families have fewer children, fewer people move to the US, and the big generation born after the Second World War is retiring.

With fewer workers for each retiree, the same tax brings in less for each retiree. So either each worker pays more, or each retiree gets less.

In the news · 20 Nov 2026

Social Security's money in and out in 2025

Since 2021, Social Security has paid out more than it took in. In 2025 it took in about $1.45 trillion and paid out $1.61 trillion.

See the story →

In the news · 20 Nov 2026

the retirement fund runs out late in 2032

The fund's bonds have covered the gap, so the fund is shrinking. The retirement fund is projected to run out late in 2032.

See the story →

In the news · 20 Nov 2026

Does that mean nothing gets paid?

78 of 100

of promised payments covered at first after the fund runs out

No. The tax keeps coming in. After the fund runs out, it would cover about 78% of promised payments at first, the official estimate says.

See the story →

In the news · 20 Nov 2026

The 22% cut would reach people already collecting. A typical couple retiring in 2033, both of whom worked, would lose about $16,900 a year, a budget watchdog estimates.

See the story →

The test

This is where the two part ways. Ponzi's investors got back under 30 cents for each dollar they put in. Social Security, short of money, would still pay about 78 cents of each dollar it promised, at first.

In the news · 20 Nov 2026

Not everyone agrees on the size of the cut. Social Security's trustees, who report on its money each year, put it at 22%. The Congressional Budget Office, Congress's own budget office, puts it at about 26%.

See the story →

Quick check

A country's pension has 4 workers paying in for each retiree. In 20 years there will be 2. The tax stays the same, and by law it can pay only what the tax brings in. What happens to payments?

Tap the answer you think is right.

Tap any other answer to see why.

The other way: save first

Swipe up to start ↑Scroll down to start ↓

The other way

There is another way to pay for later: save first. A funded plan puts money aside each year and invests it until the bills come.

In the news · 20 Nov 2026

Minimum savings for condo associations

A US rule in the news works this way. From 4 January 2027, the groups that run condo buildings would have to save 15% of owners' yearly fees for repairs, up from 10%, to keep ordinary home loans.

See the story →

In the news · 20 Nov 2026

A condo is a flat whose owners share the cost of the building they live in. Under the rule, they pay for a future roof now, bit by bit, not all at once when it fails.

See the story →

In the news · 20 Nov 2026

Five US housing groups asked for the start to be pushed back to 4 January 2028. They say they back the savings, so the fight is over timing.

See the story →

In the news · 20 Nov 2026

Saving first is hard for people paying today. Older buildings and owners on modest incomes would be hit hardest, the groups' letter says.

See the story →

Seen it before · 1997

Canada's state pension was mostly pay-as-you-go too. In 1997 Canada raised what workers and employers pay together from 6% of pay, up to a limit, to 9.9% by 2003, and began investing the extra.

20 of 100

funded by 2014, as planned

It set up a board to invest the money. The plan was expected to be about 20% funded by 2014: a fifth of what it owed, saved up.

The catch

Each way has its own risk. A funded plan depends on markets: a crash shrinks the savings. A pay-as-you-go plan depends on how many workers there are.

Switching from one to the other is hard. During the switch, workers must pay for today's retirees and save for their own, at once. Economists call it the double burden.

Quick check

A town puts aside a little tax every year and invests it, to pay for a bridge it will need in 30 years. Which plan is this, and what could go wrong?

Tap the answer you think is right.

Tap any other answer to see why.

When it runs short, who decides?

Swipe up to start ↑Scroll down to start ↓

In the news · 20 Nov 2026

By law, Social Security can pay only what its fund and its tax hold. So unless the US Congress acts before 2032, payments fall to what the tax covers.

See the story →

The levers

There are only three ways to close the gap: more money in, less money paid out, or money from somewhere else.

In the news · 20 Nov 2026

In 1983 the retirement fund was months from running short. Congress raised the tax and the retirement age.

See the story →

The age for a full pension rose in steps from 65 to 67, reaching 67 for people born in 1960 or later. For the first time, part of some retirees' pensions was taxed, too.

In the news · 20 Nov 2026

Using the tax alone this time would take a rise of 4.42 points now, from 12.4% to about 16.8%, Social Security's trustees estimate.

See the story →

In the news · 20 Nov 2026

Johnson's bill takes the third lever: pay from the government's general taxes. The government already spends more than they raise, so the US Treasury, its money department, would borrow the difference.

See the story →

In the news · 20 Nov 2026

A budget watchdog, CRFB, puts that at about $190 trillion of extra US debt over 75 years.

See the story →

In the news · 20 Nov 2026

CRFB's estimate of home loan rates if general taxes paid the pensions

Borrowing reaches people who are not retired, like young home buyers. An earlier CRFB study found it could push the interest on a 30-year home loan from 6.3% to 8.9%.

See the story →

In the news · 20 Nov 2026

From October 2024 to April 2025, 267,000 more people applied to start collecting than a year before, up 13%. Researchers blame turmoil at the agency and fear for the program.

See the story →

In the news · 20 Nov 2026

Starting at 62 pays 30% less a month than waiting until 67. The lower payment lasts for life, though it starts five years sooner.

See the story →

The idea

Every worker paying in today is paying for someone's parents, and will be paid by someone's children. Each vote on the law decides who carries the gap.

Quick check

Another country's pension fund runs out. By law it can pay only what its tax brings in, which covers 70% of what it promised. Nobody votes to change anything. What happens?

Tap the answer you think is right.

Tap any other answer to see why.

What to carry

Swipe up to start ↑Scroll down to start ↓

Carry this · 1 of 3

A Ponzi scheme hides where its money comes from and needs ever more new money; when that stops, almost nothing is left.

Carry this · 2 of 3

A pay-as-you-go pension pays this year's retirees with this year's workers' tax, openly and by law, and needs a steady number of workers for each retiree, not a growing number.

Carry this · 3 of 3

When there are fewer workers for each retiree, the gap is closed by more tax, smaller payments or borrowed money, and a vote decides who carries it.

That's the course.

Is Social Security a Ponzi scheme? 5 parts, about 14 minutes.