Thursday, 27 August 2026
27 August 2026
- In brief
- 1The winner's curse: why winning a bidding war usually means having judged the price worst
- 2England and Wales move to binding sales
- 3Stamp duty may move to the seller
- 4Australia's auction habit is shrinking
- 5Victoria will make sellers publish the reserve
- 6Nearly £5.9bn of UK property sold under the hammer
- 7A card settlement breaks the all-cards rule
- 8A 13-month clock decides who gets scam money back
- 9Banks wrongly refused a third of fraud complaints
- 10Owning a home costs nearly as much as buying it
- TruthThe truth, across the day
27 Aug · Money · In brief
Money · Thursday, 27 August 2026
Money, in brief
10 stories · 31 sources
Swipe up for the day in brief ↑Scroll down for the day in brief ↓
What is moving · 1 of 4
Fear of missing out
a crowd signals demand, and the signal pushes bids past value
What is moving · 2 of 4
Buyer bargaining power
18.8% of US listings carried a price cut in June
What is moving · 3 of 4
The information gap
most Australian sellers need not reveal a reserve price
What is moving · 4 of 4
Faith in the auction
Australian auction listings fell about 20% in a year
The winner's curse: why winning a bidding war usually means having judged the price worst
Swipe up for the story ↑Scroll down for the story ↓
A study of nearly 14 million US home sales found buyers who paid above the asking price earned about 1.3 percentage points less each year.
Who is involved
Steve Choi and colleagues
measured the curse in housing for the first time, across 14 million sales [2]
Who is involved
Richard Thaler and Alex Imas
named the pattern in 1992 and republished it in late 2025 [4][5]
Three Atlantic Richfield engineers
spotted it first in Gulf of Mexico drilling bids [1]
Why it matters
Watch whether published reserve prices calm the bidding in Victoria or simply move the anchor upward - the same reform could plausibly do either.
How it works
The prize goes to whoever was most wrong
How it works
When nobody can value a thing, an auction does not find its true price - it finds the largest overestimate in the room.
How it works · step 1 of 5
Nobody knows what the thing is really worth
How it works · step 2 of 5
Each bidder guesses, and every guess is a little off
How it works · step 3 of 5
The rule of the auction hands it to the highest guess
How it works · step 4 of 5
So the winner is whoever overestimated by the most
How it works · step 5 of 5
Add bidders and the top guess climbs further from the truth
The twist
Winning is not proof of good judgement - it is evidence against it, because the room hands the thing to whoever was furthest out.
The catch
It only bites where the value is uncertain and roughly the same for everybody.
The catch
If a thing is genuinely worth more to one buyer than to any other, paying most can be right.
The whole
Every bidder in that room was careful, and the room still produced a price nobody thought sensible.
The whole
A seat in that room shows one number - its own - which is why a room can be wrong while everyone in it is reasonable.
Why it works on people
Winning arrives instantly and feels like judgement rewarded, while the price is only tested years later, when the house is sold again.
Who gains
Sellers in a bidding war
The overpayment is money that moves straight from the winning buyer to them.
Who pays
Lower-income, Black and Hispanic buyers
The study found they are more likely to overpay in a bidding war, and so more exposed to weak returns and default.
Nobody knows yet
How many US buyers actually paid under the price last year.
Two figures circulate for the same period: 62% below the original listing price, and 60% below asking. They are not the same measure.
Nobody knows yet
Whether the winner's curse works the same way outside the United States.
The 14-million-sale study covers US housing only, and its author says other countries remain an open question.
Nobody knows yet
Whether publishing reserve prices will cool bidding or raise it.
The same analysis says clearer signals could temper emotional bidding, or anchor buyers higher if sellers respond with bolder reserves.
Good news
For thirty years the winner's curse was mostly a story economists told each other. Now fourteen million sales have measured it, which is how a hunch becomes something anyone can be warned about.
The short version
That's the story in short.
The whole story has 21 more parts.
or swipe up for the next storyor scroll on for the next story ↓
The whole story, in 21 parts ↓
Part 1 of 21 · Who else is involved
Victoria's state government
will force sellers to publish reserve prices before auction [11]
Part 2 of 21 · How it unfolded
2017
Thaler wins the Nobel memorial prize in economics
This year
the first large-scale housing evidence for the curse arrives
Part 2 of 21 · How it unfolded
This year
the first large-scale housing evidence for the curse arrives
Next year
Victoria's reserve-price law goes to state parliament
Part 3 of 21
Held for the typical 6.3 years, that gap works out at roughly an 8.2% overpayment.
Part 4 of 21
Bidding-war winners were also 1.9 percentage points more likely to default on the mortgage.
Part 5 of 21
They resold faster than other buyers, which suggests the extra money bought auction fever rather than a house they loved.
Part 6 of 21
The cause is arithmetic, not foolishness: everyone guesses, the highest guess wins, so the winner is whoever overestimated most.
Part 7 of 21
An auction sells to the highest bid, whether the bidding is open in a room or sealed in envelopes.
Part 8 of 21
Three engineers at an oil company named it, after noticing the drilling plots they won held less oil than expected.
Part 9 of 21
Richard Thaler collected it in a 1992 book of economic oddities, and published a new edition with Alex Imas last November.
Part 10 of 21
It runs well beyond auction rooms - house bidding wars, company takeovers and clubs chasing young players all have the same shape.
Part 11 of 21
A four-bedroom Yorkshire Dales house guided at £19,000 drew 123 bids and sold for £263,000.
Part 12 of 21
Its buyer inherited a 1996 planning condition requiring an occupant to work at the local pub, which closed in 2025.
Part 13 of 21
The effect is uneven: the study found lower-income, Black and Hispanic buyers are more likely to overpay in a bidding war.
Part 14 of 21
San Francisco is the exception, with single-family prices up about 17% in a year to a $2.2m median while supply fell roughly 45%.
Part 15 of 21
Most of the US market runs the other way - about 62% of buyers paid below the original list price last year, the highest share since 2019.
Part 16 of 21
In June about 18.8% of American listings carried a price cut, and the median asking price was down 2.5% on a year earlier.
Part 17 of 21
Nashville shows the swing: a median listing price of $453,000 in early 2022, a $590,000 peak in July 2023, then $529,000 by March 2026.
Part 18 of 21
Zoopla put the average UK home about £16,000 below its listing price last November, with price growth down to 1.3% a year.
Part 19 of 21
Sellers are warned about the mirror risk - price too high and the home sits, price too low and money is left on the table.
Part 20 of 21
What tips a market toward buyers is simply more homes than buyers, which shows up as longer selling times and price competition.
Part 21 of 21
Australia sells homes by open outcry auction, and Victoria will soon force sellers to publish their reserve price seven days ahead.
16 sources
The winner's curse: why winning a bidding war usually means having judged the price worst
- 1Winner's Curse in Auctions: Causes, Impacts, and Examples
- 2Winning a bidding war isn't always a win, research on 14 million home sales shows
- 3How to avoid 'The Winner's Curse'
- 4Richard Thaler and The Winner's Curse
- 5'The Winner's Curse' by Richard Thaler and Alex O. Imas
- 6Home linked to pub job sells for 14 times estimate
- 7'Absolutely bananas': San Francisco homes sell for $1m above asking price amid AI boom
- 8The Housing Market Is Swinging Toward Buyers
- 960% of home buyers paid below asking price in 2025
- 105 Signs Home Buyers Have More Negotiating Power Right Now
- 11Victoria will force home sellers to reveal their reserve price. Will other states follow?
- 17'Be bold but calculated': how to get a low offer on buying a home accepted
- 26Understanding Auctions: Types, Benefits, and How They Work
- 27Selling Smart: Keep Emotions Out of Your Home Pricing Strategy
- 28HomeBuyer Beware, Even In An Increasingly Buyer's Market
- 29Buyer's Market Explained: Key Features and Real Estate Impact
The full story
The winner's curse: why winning a bidding war usually means having judged the price worst
A study of nearly 14 million US home sales found buyers who paid above the asking price earned about 1.3 percentage points less each year.
Held for the typical 6.3 years, that gap works out at roughly an 8.2% overpayment.
Bidding-war winners were also 1.9 percentage points more likely to default on the mortgage.
They resold faster than other buyers, which suggests the extra money bought auction fever rather than a house they loved.
The cause is arithmetic, not foolishness: everyone guesses, the highest guess wins, so the winner is whoever overestimated most.
An auction sells to the highest bid, whether the bidding is open in a room or sealed in envelopes.
Three engineers at an oil company named it, after noticing the drilling plots they won held less oil than expected.
Richard Thaler collected it in a 1992 book of economic oddities, and published a new edition with Alex Imas last November.
It runs well beyond auction rooms - house bidding wars, company takeovers and clubs chasing young players all have the same shape.
A four-bedroom Yorkshire Dales house guided at £19,000 drew 123 bids and sold for £263,000.
Its buyer inherited a 1996 planning condition requiring an occupant to work at the local pub, which closed in 2025.
The effect is uneven: the study found lower-income, Black and Hispanic buyers are more likely to overpay in a bidding war.
San Francisco is the exception, with single-family prices up about 17% in a year to a $2.2m median while supply fell roughly 45%.
Most of the US market runs the other way - about 62% of buyers paid below the original list price last year, the highest share since 2019.
In June about 18.8% of American listings carried a price cut, and the median asking price was down 2.5% on a year earlier.
Nashville shows the swing: a median listing price of $453,000 in early 2022, a $590,000 peak in July 2023, then $529,000 by March 2026.
Zoopla put the average UK home about £16,000 below its listing price last November, with price growth down to 1.3% a year.
Sellers are warned about the mirror risk - price too high and the home sits, price too low and money is left on the table.
What tips a market toward buyers is simply more homes than buyers, which shows up as longer selling times and price competition.
Australia sells homes by open outcry auction, and Victoria will soon force sellers to publish their reserve price seven days ahead.
Why it matters. Watch whether published reserve prices calm the bidding in Victoria or simply move the anchor upward - the same reform could plausibly do either.
England and Wales move to binding sales
Swipe up for the story ↑Scroll down for the story ↓
Ministers propose making an accepted offer legally binding much earlier, with a financial penalty for pulling out without good reason. Scotland already works this way.
Why it matters
Gazumped buyers currently have no legal recourse, and Rightmove says more than one in five sales fall through.
1 source
England and Wales move to binding sales
The full story
England and Wales move to binding sales
Ministers propose making an accepted offer legally binding much earlier, with a financial penalty for pulling out without good reason. Scotland already works this way.
Why it matters. Gazumped buyers currently have no legal recourse, and Rightmove says more than one in five sales fall through.
Stamp duty may move to the seller
Swipe up for the story ↑Scroll down for the story ↓
The UK government is said to be weighing a shift so the tax falls on sellers and only above a threshold, hitting London and the south-east hardest.
Why it matters
One study found a two-point rise cut how often people move by 37%, which is a tax on the wrong thing.
1 source
Stamp duty may move to the seller
The full story
Stamp duty may move to the seller
The UK government is said to be weighing a shift so the tax falls on sellers and only above a threshold, hitting London and the south-east hardest.
Why it matters. One study found a two-point rise cut how often people move by 37%, which is a tax on the wrong thing.
Australia's auction habit is shrinking
Swipe up for the story ↑Scroll down for the story ↓
Total listings rose 22.8% over twelve months while auction listings fell about 20%, and roughly 40% of listed homes now sell before the auction happens.
Why it matters
Thirteen years of data show a home that fails at auction later sells about 1.3% below what a private sale would have made.
Who gains
Estate agents running auction campaigns
An auction removes the back-and-forth of private negotiation, which the researchers name as its main practical advantage.
3 sources
Australia's auction habit is shrinking
The full story
Australia's auction habit is shrinking
Total listings rose 22.8% over twelve months while auction listings fell about 20%, and roughly 40% of listed homes now sell before the auction happens.
Why it matters. Thirteen years of data show a home that fails at auction later sells about 1.3% below what a private sale would have made.
Victoria will make sellers publish the reserve
Swipe up for the story ↑Scroll down for the story ↓
Agents must disclose the seller's genuine reserve price at least seven days before an auction, under laws going to state parliament next year.
Why it matters
It targets underquoting - advertising below the expected price to build a crowd - already illegal but hard to police while reserves stay private.
1 source
Victoria will make sellers publish the reserve
The full story
Victoria will make sellers publish the reserve
Agents must disclose the seller's genuine reserve price at least seven days before an auction, under laws going to state parliament next year.
Why it matters. It targets underquoting - advertising below the expected price to build a crowd - already illegal but hard to police while reserves stay private.
Nearly £5.9bn of UK property sold under the hammer
Swipe up for the story ↑Scroll down for the story ↓
Auction sales rose from £5.5bn in 2024 to almost £5.9bn in 2025, and England and Wales recorded 14,025 mortgage repossession orders in 2024.
Why it matters
One lot in a London room carried a guide price of £1, and one seller was in the room, still living in the house.
Who gains
Buyers of repossessed stock
Nearly £5.9bn of property reached UK auction rooms in 2025, some of it guided at a few thousand pounds.
Who pays
The woman whose home sold while she stood in the room
Three hundred lots went through one London sale, hers among them, and the gavel did not pause for her.
1 source
Nearly £5.9bn of UK property sold under the hammer
The full story
Nearly £5.9bn of UK property sold under the hammer
Auction sales rose from £5.5bn in 2024 to almost £5.9bn in 2025, and England and Wales recorded 14,025 mortgage repossession orders in 2024.
Why it matters. One lot in a London room carried a guide price of £1, and one seller was in the room, still living in the house.
A card settlement breaks the all-cards rule
Swipe up for the story ↑Scroll down for the story ↓
A settlement between Visa, Mastercard and US merchants ends the rule forcing a shop that takes one Visa credit card to take every Visa credit card.
Why it matters
It opens tiered pricing at the till, the promised fee cuts run out after five years, and the fee itself is roughly 1% to 3%.
Who gains
Card-issuing banks
A fee of roughly 1% to 3% on every card sale funds the rewards offered to the same shoppers.
Who pays
Shoppers who pay cash
The swipe fee is charged to the shop, never printed on the receipt, and can reach the shelf price everyone meets.
4 sources
A card settlement breaks the all-cards rule
The full story
A card settlement breaks the all-cards rule
A settlement between Visa, Mastercard and US merchants ends the rule forcing a shop that takes one Visa credit card to take every Visa credit card.
Why it matters. It opens tiered pricing at the till, the promised fee cuts run out after five years, and the fee itself is roughly 1% to 3%.
A 13-month clock decides who gets scam money back
Swipe up for the story ↑Scroll down for the story ↓
UK rules from October 2024 promise repayment within five working days up to £85,000, but the bank must be told within thirteen months of the last payment.
Why it matters
One woman paid £19,000 in October 2024 and only realised in March 2026; Lloyds refunded in full a day after BBC Money Box asked.
Who pays
Scam victims who realise late
A £19,000 payment made in October 2024 was refused because the loss was only noticed in March 2026.
Nobody knows yet
How many scam claims die on the 13-month deadline.
The banks' trade body says the number is small but publishes no figure, and the clock runs from the payment rather than the discovery.
1 source
A 13-month clock decides who gets scam money back
The full story
A 13-month clock decides who gets scam money back
UK rules from October 2024 promise repayment within five working days up to £85,000, but the bank must be told within thirteen months of the last payment.
Why it matters. One woman paid £19,000 in October 2024 and only realised in March 2026; Lloyds refunded in full a day after BBC Money Box asked.
Banks wrongly refused a third of fraud complaints
Swipe up for the story ↑Scroll down for the story ↓
The ombudsman judged Monzo wrong in 34% of 3,372 cases, NatWest in 33% of 1,972 and HSBC in 32% of 2,535.
Why it matters
Industry figures counted 185,733 tricked-transfer cases in 2024, with £450.7m taken and £267.1m repaid.
1 source
Banks wrongly refused a third of fraud complaints
The full story
Banks wrongly refused a third of fraud complaints
The ombudsman judged Monzo wrong in 34% of 3,372 cases, NatWest in 33% of 1,972 and HSBC in 32% of 2,535.
Why it matters. Industry figures counted 185,733 tricked-transfer cases in 2024, with £450.7m taken and £267.1m repaid.
Owning a home costs nearly as much as buying it
Swipe up for the story ↑Scroll down for the story ↓
Typical American non-mortgage home costs reached $24,529 a year, up from $17,958, against the $26,508 a year spent on the mortgage itself.
Why it matters
Closing costs add a national average of $4,661, about 1.6% of the average sale price, and only 37% know a 20% deposit is not required.
3 sources
Owning a home costs nearly as much as buying it
The full story
Owning a home costs nearly as much as buying it
Typical American non-mortgage home costs reached $24,529 a year, up from $17,958, against the $26,508 a year spent on the mortgage itself.
Why it matters. Closing costs add a national average of $4,661, about 1.6% of the average sale price, and only 37% know a 20% deposit is not required.
The truth, across the day
Swipe up for the truth ↑Scroll down for the truth ↓
What's really going on
An auction is sold as a way of finding a thing's true price, but where the value is unknown it mostly finds the largest error in the room.
That's the whole Money day.
10 stories, 31 sources.