Food & Farming · Tuesday, 29 September 2026
India's Supreme Court tells the food regulator to stop delaying red warning labels. Food companies say shoppers already read red as 'not vegetarian'
India's Supreme Court asked why the food regulator needs four months plus a year to put red warnings on packs high in salt, sugar or fat. The food industry's lobby group wants another colour and looser limits.
4 months + 1 year
the time India's food regulator says it needs before red warnings are compulsory
India's Supreme Court asked why it wants so much time
3%
added sugar, by weight of a solid food, above which a red warning would appear
Reuters says India's limits are stricter than in many other countries; the fat limit is 4.2%
180m to 450m
overweight or obese adults in India in 2021, and the number projected for 2050
from a study in the medical journal The Lancet
The lead story — what happened
-
India's Supreme Court asked on Monday why the country's food regulator needs so long to bring in warning labels on packaged food.
[1] -
Justice J.B. Pardiwala asked why the regulator wanted to "waste so much time" when the court was worried about health, and what it had done in the last four years.
[1] -
The regulator, the Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI), told the court last week that it needs about four months to finish the rules.
[2] -
Companies would then get one more year before the warnings become compulsory.
[2] -
The court said it would soon issue a final order.
[1] -
The plan puts a red six-sided mark on the front of packs high in salt, sugar or fat.
[1] In a filing on 23 September, FSSAI said one high nutrient will be enough to trigger it; its earlier plan needed two.[2] -
The All India Food Processors Association, which speaks for dozens of Indian and foreign food companies, filed its objections on 24 September.
[1] -
It says it is not against warnings, but asks for a colour other than red.
[1] It says Indian shoppers already know red as the compulsory mark for food that is not vegetarian.[1] -
It also objects to how the limits are applied, such as a warning when added sugar is more than 3% of a solid food's weight.
[1] Reuters says that limit is stricter than in many other countries.[1] -
It again asked for limits measured on one serving, not on 100 grams, saying Indians eat foods like pickle about 10 grams at a time.
[1] -
India's packaged-food industry is worth more than $100 billion, and Reuters calls India a top growth market for PepsiCo, Coca-Cola, Mondelez and Nestle.
[1] -
Chile made similar warnings law in 2016. A study in The Lancet found girls exposed to the law for 18 months had a 2.85% lower chance of being overweight, and firms changed many recipes.
[3]
Who is involved
-
Justice J.B. Pardiwala
a judge of India's Supreme Court; he is hearing the case activists brought over the labels
[1] -
FSSAI
India's food regulator; it wrote the red-warning plan and asks for four months plus a year
[2] -
All India Food Processors Association
a lobby group for dozens of Indian and foreign food companies; it wants another colour and looser limits
[1] -
PepsiCo, Coca-Cola, Mondelez and Nestle
global food and drink companies; Reuters calls India one of their top growth markets
[1]
How it unfolded
-
23 Sep FSSAI tells the court that one high nutrient will trigger a warning, and gives its timetable
[2] -
24 Sep the food companies' association files its objections to the colour and the limits
[1] -
28 Sep India's Supreme Court asks why the regulator wants so much time
[1] -
6 Oct comments close on a separate plan to limit junk-food sales near schools
[3] -
Next the court's final order, which it says is coming soon
[1]
Where this points
Watch the court's final order: whether it keeps the warnings red, and whether it shortens the four months plus a year the regulator asked for.
What is pushing on the whole day
The bar and the word are our reading of how hard each one is pushing today. The arrow is where it is heading. The evidence is in the stories below.
India's Supreme Court is pushing the country's food regulator to bring in red warnings sooner.
The Trump administration is weighing cheaper, untaxed diesel for more buyers as the elections near.
On Jersey, an island between England and France, apple and cereal harvests fell by 90% and 50% after a hot, dry summer.
COFCO and Sinograin, China's state grain companies, have bought more than 12 million tonnes of US soybeans.
The rest of the day
12 more stories on this beat.
Each with its own sources. None of these is a link to the story above.
-
02
China cuts its tax on US farm goods, but not soybeans
China's commerce ministry published a list on Monday of US farm goods whose tariffs it will cut, including corn, wheat, sorghum, meat, dairy, soymeal and soy oil.
[4] Soybeans, the US farm product China imports most, were left off and still pay an extra 10%.[4] Traders say that tax is too high for China's private oilseed mills to absorb.[4] China's state firms have bought more than 12 million tonnes of US soybeans, nearly half the 25 million tonnes a year the US government says China promised.[4] US soybeans bought by China's state firms so far12 m tonnesThe yearly amount the US government says China promised25 m tonnesChina's state firms have bought more than 12 million tonnes of US soybeans. The US government says China agreed to buy 25 million tonnes a year through 2028. Why it matters — China has taken about half of all US soybean exports in recent years.
[5] A Chinese analyst, Feng Chucheng, says keeping soybean buying on a separate track gives China leverage before the US elections in November.[4] -
03
California creates a 'not ultra-processed' badge
California's governor, Gavin Newsom, signed a law on 28 September creating a voluntary 'Non-Ultraprocessed Certified' label for packed food.
[6] Foods with added dyes, flavour enhancers, sweeteners without sugar or processing aids cannot carry it.[6] The state's public health department will approve outside firms to check products, and each product must be checked again at least every three years.[6] Last year California passed what state officials called the first US legal definition of ultra-processed food, to phase such foods out of schools.[6] Why it matters — Using the badge is each company's choice, so it will appear only on foods that pass.
[6] Non-UPF Verified, a private group that runs its own badge, asked Newsom to veto the law because it ignores how food is processed.[6] -
04
England's food watchdog plans to study big firms' data
The board of Britain's Food Standards Agency, the body that oversees food safety, has approved the next stage of a plan to change how food is checked in England.
[7] Ten national supermarket chains sell more than 97% of the food bought in shops, while more than 99.5% of food businesses are small or medium-sized.[7] So the agency wants a national team to study the biggest firms' own safety records, starting with supermarkets, alongside local council inspectors.[7] Its board will review the detail in March 2027, before a public consultation.[7] Why it matters — A pilot with big retailers found their own data could show safety risks across a whole company.
[7] Chris McGarvey, who once led the agency's legal team, warns that data it holds could be released under freedom-of-information law.[7] -
05
US weighs untaxed diesel for more buyers
The Trump administration is considering letting more buyers use red-dyed diesel, people familiar with the talks told Reuters.
[8] Dyed diesel is normally kept for off-road work such as farming, and it skips the federal tax of 24.4 cents a gallon.[8] It is one alternative to a ban on diesel exports, which Trump says he is weighing 'very seriously'.[8] Alabama, Louisiana and Nebraska have already loosened their own rules on dyed diesel.[8] The US average diesel price is above $6 a gallon.[8] Why it matters — Farmers already buy untaxed dyed diesel, so the change would mainly help truckers, said Patrick De Haan of GasBuddy, a fuel-price tracker.
[8] He does not expect it to add any diesel or cut what drivers pay.[8] -
06
UN starts vaccinating 9.8 million animals in Sudan
The UN's food agency, FAO, has started a campaign to vaccinate 9.8 million farm animals across all 18 of Sudan's states.
[9] It aims to protect 1.2 million families who keep livestock, whose milk also feeds children.[9] Sudan's war, which began in April 2023, destroyed the national laboratory that made up to 35 million animal vaccine doses a year.[9] FAO imported about 23 million doses in 2025, and vaccinated 8.4 million animals between October 2025 and July 2026.[9] Money FAO has for its Sudan work$44.10mMoney FAO asked for, 2026 to 2028$193mFAO's emergency farm money for Sudan, against the amount in its appeal for 2026 to 2028. Why it matters — FAO says the war has cost Sudan's herders nearly $3 billion in lost livestock.
[9] It has $44.1 million for its Sudan work, against the $193 million it asked for.[9] -
07
Mondelez hands its wheat badge to an outside body
Mondelez, the company that owns Cadbury, is turning Harmony, its own scheme for greener wheat farming, into an independent badge.
[10] [3] Harmony began in 2008 and now covers 1,200 farmers, 18 flour mills and 57,000 hectares of wheat in Europe.[10] The ProTerra Foundation, a non-profit that runs certification schemes, will govern it, and other companies can join.[10] The change comes as a European Union rule takes effect that sets standards for green labels to be run independently.[10] Why it matters — Other farmers, millers and companies can now use the badge without being tied to Mondelez.
[10] FoodNavigator, a food-industry news site, asks whether it could become the common standard for European wheat.[10] -
08
Jersey's apples fall to a 50-year low
Jersey, a small island between England and France, averaged 20.5C from June to August, against 17.7C over the last 30 years, its weather service says.
[11] Apple and cereal growers there say their harvests are down 90% and 50%.[11] La Mare Vineyard picked three or four tonnes of apples instead of the usual 60 or 70, its smallest crop in 50 years.[11] One farm says it watered every crop several times over, buying diesel to run the pumps.[11] 60-70 tonnesA usual apple crop3-4 tonnesThis year's cropApples picked at La Mare Vineyard on Jersey. This year's crop was about a twentieth of a normal one, its smallest in 50 years. Why it matters — Jersey's government says its farm support fund is fixed, but it may spend it differently.
[11] Tim Crowley of La Mare says growers used to plan on 30-year weather averages and now look at five-year ones.[11] -
09
China's private mills buy Australian canola again
A private Chinese company that presses oilseeds has bought 68,000 tonnes of Australia's new canola crop for March, trade sources told Reuters.
[12] Another private buyer's cargo arrived earlier in September.[12] They are the first private purchases since 2020, when China shut out Australian canola over fears of a fungal plant disease.[12] China reopened the trade in mid-2025 through COFCO, a state company, and let private firms back in July.[12] Why it matters — Canola, also called rapeseed, is pressed into cooking oil and animal feed, and China imports more of it than any other country.
[12] Canada, the biggest exporter, is in a trade dispute with China, and Australia is the second-biggest.[12] -
10
Farm robot makers grow to 400
The Mixing Bowl, a group that tracks farm and food technology, counted 400 companies making robots for crop farms this year, 25% more than in 2024.
[13] About a fifth of the companies it listed before are gone, and more than a third are new.[13] Half are in Europe, and more than 40% of the US firms are in California.[13] Together they have raised about $600 million.[13] Spraying and weeding robots are the most popular with investors.[13] Why it matters — Big machine makers are buying in: Deere bought GUSS, a maker of self-driving sprayers, in 2025, and Kubota led an investment in Kilter.
[13] Better-funded startups are buying smaller ones too, as Bonsai Robotics did with Farm-ng.[13] -
11
Cold snaps cut China's rice more than models said
A study in Communications Earth & Environment, a journal from the publisher of Nature, looked at 4,193 extreme cold days at 218 sites in China from 1991 to 2012.
[14] Extreme cold days became twice as common over two decades, even as the world warmed.[14] The cold cut China's national rice yields by about 5%, mostly while plants were growing and forming grain.[14] The authors project a further 3% loss by 2100, three times what climate models alone suggest.[14] Why it matters — Research on climate and crops has mostly studied heat, the authors say, so the risk from cold has been underestimated.
[14] They offer their method as a test for rice areas elsewhere that face cold.[14] -
12
A tenth of the world's land is worn out
The UN's food agency, FAO, says in its new State of the World's Forests report that more than 460 million hectares of forest are degraded.
[15] More than 10% of all land, 1.56 billion hectares, is degraded, about 53 times the size of Italy.[15] Countries have pledged to restore more than a billion hectares over two decades.[15] FAO says at least 470 million hectares must be under restoration by 2030 to meet global goals.[15] Why it matters — FAO puts the cost of doing nothing about worn-out land at $878 billion to $6.3 trillion a year.
[15] It says restoring land also helps food supplies and rural families.[15] -
13
Chemical found in blood near an English plant
Forty-nine people living near a chemical factory in Thornton-Cleveleys, in north-west England, volunteered for blood tests, and 70% had raised levels of PFOA.
[16] PFOA is a 'forever chemical', one that barely breaks down; the factory, now run by AGC Chemicals, used it until 2012.[16] England's Environment Agency has spent years investigating it in local soil and home-grown food.[16] Residents were advised to stop eating eggs from their own hens and ducks.[16] Why it matters — Hens scratch in the soil and eat worms, so the chemical can pass into their eggs, one resident said.
[16] The UK Health Security Agency does not recommend blood tests, saying they give individuals little clear information.[16]
Why food makers accept a badge and fight a warning
Companies choose which foods carry a badge, but a law chooses which foods carry a warning, so food companies fight the warning.
The twist
California's new badge will only appear on foods that already pass, so no company has to change anything. India's red warning must appear on the foods that fail, so the companies that make them are fighting over its colour and its limits.
The picture
How it works
- A badge is optional, so a maker puts it only on foods that already pass
- So a badge changes no recipe and costs the maker little
- A warning is compulsory, so it goes on every food over the limit
- That includes best-selling snacks, whose sales can fall
- So makers argue over the warning's colour, its limits and how much food it is measured on
The same force, elsewhere today
Where this chain is also running, in today's other stories.
-
California's 'not ultra-processed' badge
Using it is each company's choice, so it will sit only on foods that pass, and a food that fails simply goes without it.
-
Mondelez hands its wheat badge to an outside body
Farms and mills choose to join Harmony, so the badge marks the wheat of those that meet its rules and says nothing about the rest.
Where you've seen this
Food hygiene stickers
In England a cafe chooses whether to show its score, so the best scores go in the window. In Wales every cafe must show its score.
Cigarette packets
Health warnings were made compulsory, and tobacco firms fought their size and wording in court.
Fridge energy labels
Every fridge sold in the EU must show its A-to-G grade, so a poor fridge cannot hide by leaving the label off.
The catch
A badge starts to matter once most rival foods carry one, because then a pack without it stands out. A warning loses force when nearly every pack on the shelf carries it.
And the whole of it
A pickle maker in India, a shopper in California and a judge in Delhi each see one part of this. Anyone reading the front of a packet is in it too, usually without knowing whether a company or a law put each mark there.
What is really going on
India's food companies told India's Supreme Court they accept warning labels, and then asked for another colour, different limits, and limits judged on one serving instead of 100 grams.
Why it works on us — A worry about confusing shoppers is easier to agree with than a complaint about limits, and the companies' filing makes both at once.
Who gains
-
Food companies selling in India
— Until the rules are final their packs carry no red warning, and the regulator has asked for four months plus a year.
[2] [1] -
US corn, wheat, sorghum, meat and dairy exporters
— China will cut its tariffs on their goods, from Monday's list.
[4] -
COFCO and Sinograin, China's state grain companies
— With the 10% soybean tax still in place, private Chinese mills stay out, which leaves US soybean buying mostly to them.
[4] [5] -
US truckers
— Wider use of dyed diesel would spare them the federal tax of 24.4 cents a gallon.
[8] -
Firms approved to check California's badge
— The law has outside certifiers check each product, and check it again at least every three years.
[6] -
The ProTerra Foundation
— It takes over Harmony, which already covers 1,200 farmers and 18 flour mills, as an EU rule on independent green labels takes effect.
[10]
Who pays
-
US soybean farmers
— Their beans still pay China's extra 10% tax, which traders say private Chinese mills cannot absorb.
[4] -
Jersey's apple and cereal growers
— Their harvests fell 90% and 50%, and one farm bought diesel to water every crop several times over.
[11] -
Families in Sudan who keep livestock
— The war destroyed the lab that made their animals' vaccines, and FAO puts their livestock losses at nearly $3 billion.
[9] -
Families near the Thornton-Cleveleys plant
— Of 49 who were tested, 70% had raised PFOA, and they were told to stop eating their own birds' eggs.
[16] -
Non-UPF Verified, a private badge-maker in California
— Its own badge now sits beside one backed by the state, and it asked the governor to veto the law.
[6]
What nobody knows yet
Open questions from across today’s stories — ours included.
-
01
What India's Supreme Court will order, and when.
The court said only that its final order would come soon.
[1] -
02
Whether India's warnings stay red.
The food companies' group asked for another colour in a filing on 24 September, and no answer from the regulator has been reported.
[1] -
03
How many packed foods would carry a red warning under India's limits.
None of today's sources gives a count, and the regulator has not published one.
[1] [2] -
04
Whether China will cut its tax on US soybeans.
Soybeans were left off Monday's list, and China's buying of them runs on a separate track from the other goods.
[4] -
05
Whether untaxed diesel for more buyers would lower anyone's fuel bill.
Reuters says the saving depends on how the relief is set up and how much sellers pass on, and GasBuddy's analyst expects no effect.
[8] -
06
How many companies will use California's badge.
It is voluntary, and the state has not yet approved the firms that will check products.
[6] -
07
Whether FAO can pay for the whole Sudan campaign.
It has $44.1 million against an appeal of $193 million.
[9] -
08
Whether England's food watchdog can keep big firms' safety data private.
Its former head of legal says freedom-of-information requests could force the data out, and the exemptions may not always apply.
[7] -
09
How much PFOA the Thornton-Cleveleys residents took in from eggs and home-grown food.
The tests measured blood only. The Environment Agency has investigated the soil and home-grown food for years, and today's source gives no result.
[16]
The UN's food agency vaccinated 8.4 million farm animals in Sudan between October 2025 and July 2026, after the war destroyed the laboratory that was the country's only maker of animal vaccines. It also sent vaccines into Darfur by a new route from Chad, for the first time.
Also true today
- China's private oilseed mills are buying Australian canola again, for the first time since 2020. One has bought 68,000 tonnes of the new crop for March.
- China will cut its tariffs on US corn, wheat, sorghum, meat and dairy, under a list its commerce ministry published on Monday.
More from Food & Farming
Across the beats