Money · Tuesday, 17 November 2026
Written by AI agents built on Claude, from the sources they cite, and overseen by Zeemish. How it's made
This day: every beat The day in 12 minutes
Companies use Trump tariff refunds for executive bonuses while shoppers who paid the higher prices get nothing back
Signals on this beat
Money not getting back to households High ↑
- TJX set aside $112 million of its tariff refund for bonuses.
[1] - Russia will move dead savers' unclaimed bank deposits to the state by mid-March 2027.
[21]
Money systems failing their users Building ↑
- Chase customers struggled to log in or move money for much of Monday.
[14] - A known UK benefits computer fault has overpaid one claimant for 18 months.
[26] - Federal retirement claims still took 73 days on average in October.
[24]
Home loans costing borrowers more Steady
- A US Senate bill would raise the fee on a VA refinance from 0.5% to 1.42% of the loan.
[18] - The FHA's insurance fund stands at 10.29%, against a legal floor of 2%, and no premium cut is planned yet.
[20]
The stories
14 on this beat today.
Each story is told in its parts: what happened, the questions that explain it, how it works, who gains and who pays, and the good news. A part appears when the sources give it.
-
01
Companies use Trump tariff refunds for executive bonuses while shoppers who paid the higher prices get nothing back
$112m of $331m
of TJX's tariff refund set aside for year-end bonuses
TJX owns the TJ Maxx and Marshalls stores
[1] $100bn
in tariff refunds paid back to importers by the end of July
roughly 60% of what the struck-down tariffs raised
[6] 9
companies found putting tariff refunds towards bonuses
none of them has ever said it would refund customers
[1] What happened
-
At least 9 US companies are putting tariff refunds towards bonuses, ProPublica found by reading their filings.
[1] -
The refunds exist because the US Supreme Court struck down Trump's broadest tariffs in February.
[6] -
Shoppers who paid much of the tariff through higher prices appear to be largely missing out on the refunds.
[1] -
A tariff is a tax on foreign goods, paid by the importer when the goods arrive at customs.
[6] -
About 330,000 importers could win back some money, the BBC reported when refunds began.
[7] -
US Customs estimated it had collected $166 billion under the tariffs the court struck down.
[12] -
By the end of July it had paid back about $100 billion, roughly 60% of the total.
[6] -
In June the US refunded $49.18 billion and took in $23.63 billion of tariffs, the Tax Foundation counted.
[9] -
Stanley Black & Decker, a big US toolmaker, raised its prices more than once and blamed the tariffs.
[1] -
It is getting at least $298 million back.
[1] It says part of that gain went on incentive pay, its word for bonuses.[1] -
Acushnet, the maker of Titleist golf gear, booked about $12 million of incentive pay out of its refund.
[1] -
None of the firms using refunds for bonuses has ever said it planned to refund customers, ProPublica found.
[1] -
Burlington, a US discount clothing chain, got $55 million back and says it will cut prices instead.
[1] -
Target got $994 million and said it would not pay refunds, but would invest in lower prices.
[8] -
FedEx said it would refund the shippers and shoppers who bore the charges, once Customs paid it.
[10] -
Firms selling to other firms often pay refunds, because their receipts listed the tariff.
[1] -
Shoppers have sued dozens of firms, including Walmart, Target, Nike and Lululemon, for a share.
[1] -
A suit against Five Below, a discount chain, says the money its customers paid belongs to them.
[3] -
A suit against Costco calls taking the money twice, from shoppers and from the US government, unjust enrichment.
[5] -
Florida shopper Sandra Alonso paid an extra $3,500 for a Chinese-made wheelchair, NPR reported.
[11]
Who is involved
Only that importer, called the importer of record, may apply to US Customs for the money back.
[1] - Companies get the refund
- Shoppers paid higher prices, get nothing
- US Customs and Border Protection the US border agency; it pays refunds only to the importers who paid the tariff
- Importer of record the only one who may claim
- Walmart sued
- Target sued
- Nike sued
- Lululemon sued
- ProPublica a US nonprofit newsroom; it read thousands of company filings and found the bonuses
- TJX the owner of TJ Maxx and Marshalls; it got $331 million back and set aside $112 million for bonuses
- Stanley Black & Decker a big US toolmaker; it raised prices over tariffs and is now getting at least $298 million back
How it unfolded
-
Apr 2025
Trump announces his broadest tariffs, on goods from more than 100 countries
[1] -
Feb 2026
The US Supreme Court strikes them down
[6] -
20 Apr
US Customs opens its online refund system
[12] -
End of July
About $100 billion has been paid back
[6] -
16 Nov
ProPublica finds refunds going to bonuses
[2]
Why it matters
The refunds lift company profits, and profit feeds the formulas that set bosses' bonuses, securities experts told ProPublica.
[1] One study put the tariffs' cost to a typical US household at about $1,000 last year.
[1] Think it through
-
1
Why can't a shopper just sue for it?
Proving how much of a price was tariff is hard, analysts say.
[4] Trade lawyer Lee Smith says 'the contract with the customer is the price'.[4] -
2
Didn't foreign countries pay the tariffs anyway?
No: US businesses paid them at customs, and they usually pass the cost on in prices.
[6] US importer paysCost added to pricesShopper pays more -
3
Where does the rest of TJX's refund go?
TJX says the rest will support its future growth.
[1] It would not say whether it will cut prices.[1] -
4
Why should a refund raise anyone's bonus?
Gregory Germain, a law professor at Syracuse, says no executive caused the extra profit, so their pay should not rise.
[1] Court rulingExtra profitNo executive caused it -
5
Is there a fair case for the bonuses?
Cornell's Nick Guest says bosses were penalised when tariffs hit profit, so rewarding them now seems reasonable.
[1] He says customers lost out too.[1] -
6
So who decides if shoppers see any of it?
Each company's managers decide, since no law limits how firms use the refunds.
[1] Shoppers are trying lawsuits, and legal analysts doubt they will succeed.[1]
How it works
Economists who study executive pay call this pay for luck: bonuses that rise with gains no boss caused.
TJX's bonus pot grew by $112 million because a court struck down tariffs, not because its bosses sold more.
[1] So TJX is paying for luck.[1] Seen it before
A shop worker on commission earns more when a heatwave sells fans, though they did nothing different.
The truth
-
What is really going on
Across today's stories, money moved away from the people who paid it: shoppers paid tariffs whose refunds went to companies, and veterans who refinance may pay for other veterans' benefits.
[1] [18] -
Why it works on people
Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent frames the refunds as money taken from the public, which moves the blame onto the Democrats who sued.
[1] - Nobody agrees how much shoppers paid: the New York Fed puts their share at 26%, Harvard Business School at 43%.
[1] A Goldman Sachs estimate says two-thirds.[5] - ProPublica could check only listed companies, which must publish their accounts.
[1] How private firms spend their refunds is unknown, so the bonus total is too.[1] -
Nobody knows yet
Which companies got tariff refunds, and how much each.
The Trump administration has not published the list and turned down ProPublica's request for it.
[1] -
Nobody knows yet
How much of TJX's $112 million bonus pot goes to top managers.
TJX says its year has not ended and it has not broken the figure down.
[1]
Good news
- FedEx, UPS and DHL said they would pass tariff refunds back to the shippers and shoppers who paid the charges, mostly without being asked.
-
At least 9 US companies are putting tariff refunds towards bonuses, ProPublica found by reading their filings.
-
02
Bank outage leaves late fees in doubt
What happened
-
A software bug at JPMorgan Chase delayed many customers' transactions on Monday.
[15] -
Chase, the biggest US bank, serves more than 86 million customers at 5,000 branches.
[13] -
Chase said customers could still reach their accounts and money.
[16] Some said they could not use cash machine cards or finish transactions at branches.[16] -
Kiplinger, a personal finance magazine, says bank outages usually last only a few hours.
[17] -
It says payments can fail during an outage, and fees can follow.
[17]
Who is involved
- Chase says money was reachable
- Customers say cards and branches failed
How it unfolded
In 2010 Chase's online banking was down for more than a day, and its chief executive apologised.
[14] - 2010 a day-long outage
- Monday a software bug
Why it matters
A payment missed during an outage can bring a late fee, though the fault was the bank's.
[14] Think it through
-
1
Who paid the late fees last time?
In 2010 Chase refunded late fees, but only to customers who called to ask.
[14] -
2
Has Chase said what it will do this time?
Its Monday statement said only that 'some transactions are taking longer than usual' to complete.
[16] -
3
So who decides whether customers get their fees back?
Chase does: in 2010 it set the terms of the refund itself.
[14]
How it works
Behavioural economists call this a default: what happens to everyone who does nothing.
In 2010 the default was to keep each late fee.
[14] Only Chase customers who called got theirs back.[14] Seen it before
A school that returns lost kit only to the pupils who come to the office and ask.
The truth
- Downdetector, a site that counts user complaints, does not confirm outages.
[14] So how many customers were really cut off is unknown.[14]
-
A software bug at JPMorgan Chase delayed many customers' transactions on Monday.
-
03
Veterans' home loan fees may rise
What happened
-
A US Senate bill would raise two fees on VA home loans, backed by the US Department of Veterans Affairs.
[18] -
The fee on a VA refinance to a lower rate would rise from 0.5% to 1.42% of the loan.
[18] -
On a $400,000 loan, that fee would go from $2,000 to $5,680.
[18] -
The fee for taking over someone else's VA loan would double, from 0.5% to 1%.
[18] -
The fee rises help pay for 60 measures on healthcare, education and jobs for veterans.
[19]
How it unfolded
The House passed its version, the Take Care of America's Veterans Act, by voice vote on Veterans Day.
[18] - Veterans Day the House passes it
- Now the Senate bill waits
Why it matters
Veterans who refinance would help pay for new benefits for other veterans, a mortgage brokers' group says.
[18] Think it through
-
1
How much would veterans pay in all?
NAMB, a group for mortgage brokers, puts the extra cost at $4 billion.
[18] That is about $3,780 for each veteran, it says.[18] $4 billionextra cost to veterans, NAMB estimates
-
2
Why charge borrowers instead of taxpayers?
NAMB's president says benefits for disabled veterans are the taxpayer's job, not the borrowing soldier's.
[18] -
3
So who decides now?
The US Senate does: its bill is on the calendar and can come up for debate and a vote.
[18]
How it works
Public finance calls this a user fee: a charge on the people who use a service, not on everyone.
Here the user fee lands on veterans who refinance, while the money pays for other veterans' benefits.
[18] Seen it before
A club that pays for new kit by raising the fee for members who book the pitch.
The truth
- Some argue the fee does not change whether a refinance pays back, NAMB's president says.
[18] He says it still raises what the loan costs.[18] -
Nobody knows yet
Whether the US Senate passes the VA fee rise.
-
A US Senate bill would raise two fees on VA home loans, backed by the US Department of Veterans Affairs.
-
04
FHA's insurance fund stays far above its floor
What happened
-
The FHA, a US agency that insures home loans, mostly for first-time buyers, reported on its fund on Monday.
[20] -
The fund's capital ratio fell to 10.29% from 11.47% a year earlier.
[20] -
The law asks for at least 2%, and the fund has stayed above that for 12 straight years.
[20] -
The FHA insured more than 935,000 home loans in the year, 83% of them for first-time buyers.
[20]
Why it matters
FHA borrowers pay a yearly insurance premium, and a cut would lower their monthly payments, lenders say.
[20] Think it through
-
1
Will the premium come down?
Not soon: Joseph Gormley, who runs Ginnie Mae, says the US government is comfortable with the fund.
[20] -
2
Who wants a cut?
The Mortgage Bankers Association wants a modest premium cut.
[20] Another lenders' group says homeowners are being overcharged.[20] -
3
So who holds the surplus?
The surplus stays in the fund, and the FHA sets the premium borrowers pay.
[20]
How it works
Insurers call this a capital ratio: money held against future claims, as a share of what is insured.
The FHA holds a 10.29% capital ratio against the loans it insures.
[20] That is far more than the 2% the law requires.[20] Seen it before
A class trip fund that keeps far more than the trips ever cost, year after year.
Why whoever is paid last keeps the windfall
Economists call it the residual claimant: everyone else's claim is fixed in advance, so whoever takes what is left gets every surprise.
The twist
A refund does not flow back to whoever paid most; it flows to whoever owns what is left over, because shoppers' share was settled at the till.
The picture
Shopperfixed: the priceTJXgets $331mThe shopper's claim ended at the till, so the refund lands on the company that holds what is left over. Step by step
- Most claims are fixed in advance: a price, a premium, a pension
- One party takes whatever is left over
- A windfall lands on that party
- So does a loss
- The fixed claims get neither
The same force, elsewhere today
Where this chain is also running, in today's other stories.
-
FHA's insurance fund
Borrowers' premiums are fixed, so the surplus from lower losses stays in the fund until the FHA chooses to cut.
-
Russia's heirless deposits
When no heir claims, the state is the one left holding what remains, so dead savers' deposits go to it.
-
Chicago's $55 billion debt
Pensions are locked in by law, so the city's taxpayers take the losses from crashes and skipped payments.
Seen it before
Shareholders
paid after workers, lenders and suppliers, so they gain most in good years and lose first in bad ones
A home bought with a mortgage
the bank's claim is fixed, so every rise or fall in the price lands on the owner
Farm rents
a tenant on a fixed rent keeps a bumper harvest, while one who shares the crop splits it
The catch
A fixed claim is only fixed while the payer survives: if a city or company fails, pensioners and lenders lose too.
And the whole of it
Most people sit on the fixed side of most deals: a wage, a receipt, a promised pension. Some also sit on the leftover side through a home or a pension fund that owns shares.
The truth
- The fund's strength rests on a forecast of future losses.
[20] HUD blames this year's fall partly on slower house price rises and forecasts of bigger losses.[20]
-
The FHA, a US agency that insures home loans, mostly for first-time buyers, reported on its fund on Monday.
-
05
Chicago's $55 billion debt squeezes services
What happened
-
Chicago owes $55 billion to lenders and its pension funds, ProPublica and WTTW News found.
[22] -
This year $3.6 billion of its $16.6 billion budget went on debt.
[22] -
Next year's plan takes $3.9 billion off the top before any service is paid for.
[22] -
Its pension funds hold less than 50% of what they owe.
[22] Most big cities' funds hold at least 75%.[22] -
The city's finance chief resigned last week after only three months in the job.
[22]
How it unfolded
In 2006 and 2007, Mayor Richard Daley stopped paying into four city pension funds.
[23] That let the city avoid a property tax rise.[23] - 2006 to 2007 payments skipped
- Now $3.9 billion off the top
Why it matters
None of that debt money fills a pothole or pays a firefighter, the report says.
[22] Think it through
-
1
Why can't the city cut pensions?
The pension promises are locked in by law and by politics, ProPublica says.
[22] -
2
How did the funds fall so far?
In 2000 they held 85% of what they owed.
[23] Two market crashes then wiped out nearly $16 billion.[23] -
3
So who carries the hole?
With pensions locked in, the city's taxpayers and its services carry it.
[22]
How it works
Public finance calls this pension underfunding: paying in less than promises cost, so today's budget looks balanced.
Daley's skipped payments kept property tax down then.
[23] That underfunding now takes $3.9 billion off the top of Chicago's budget.[22] The idea, in story 04: Why whoever is paid last keeps the windfall →Seen it before
Skipping your monthly saving for a bike feels fine until the birthday comes.
The truth
-
What is really going on
In Chicago, residents now pay for pension payments a mayor skipped twenty years ago.
[23] - Chicago's credit rating sits 2 or 3 levels above junk, so each new loan costs it more.
[22]
-
Chicago owes $55 billion to lenders and its pension funds, ProPublica and WTTW News found.
-
06
Russia moves to take dead savers' deposits
What happened
-
Russia's President Vladimir Putin signed a decree moving dead people's unclaimed bank savings to the state.
[21] -
It covers roubles, foreign money and precious metals held in bank accounts and deposits.
[21] -
It applies to Russians dead for more than five years, with no inheritance case and no known debts.
[21] -
Russia's government cited a law against 'unfriendly' countries, and has not explained why.
[21]
How it unfolded
- Mid-March 2027 banks hand over savings
- 1 April 2027 a law is due
Why it matters
Families who never opened an inheritance case could lose a relative's savings without knowing it.
[21] Think it through
-
1
What if an heir turns up later?
They must go to court, and have 6 months to apply once they learn of the money.
[21] -
2
Do they get the dollars or gold back?
No: an heir gets roubles equal to what reached the state budget, the decree says.
[21] Gold or dollars heldBanks pay the state in roublesHeir gets roubles -
3
So who moves first?
The state does, and a family must then prove its claim in court.
[21]
How it works
Lawyers call it heirless property: what is left when nobody inherits passes to the state.
Russia's civil code already sends heirless property to the state but needs a law saying how.
[21] The decree sets that process before the law exists.[21] The idea, in story 04: Why whoever is paid last keeps the windfall →Seen it before
Lost property at school goes to the office, and after a while it is given away.
The truth
- Nobody knows how much is held: Sberbank's deputy chairman put dormant deposits at about 200 billion roubles in 2009.
[21] A banker in 2018 suggested nearly 1.5 trillion.[21]
What comes next
Banks must hand the money over by mid-March 2027.
[21] Russia's government must propose a proper law by 1 April 2027.[21] -
Russia's President Vladimir Putin signed a decree moving dead people's unclaimed bank savings to the state.
-
07
US pensions move online for $1.5 million
What happened
-
US federal workers can now apply to retire online, after decades of paper forms.
[24] -
He says contractors spent about $100 million over 20 years and produced nothing.
[24] His team built it for about $1.5 million, he says.[24] -
Personnel files were kept in a limestone mine in western Pennsylvania.
[24] -
The Office of Personnel Management says it handled over 155,000 online applications in a year.
[24]
Who is involved
Joe Gebbia, an Airbnb co-founder, is now the US government's chief design officer.
[24] - Joe Gebbia
Why it matters
Under the paper system some retirees waited months for their full pension.
[24] Think it through
-
1
Has the wait gone?
No: claims took 73 days on average in October.
[24] Online claims took 59 days and paper ones 150.[24] Days to process
Online59Paper150retirement claims in October -
2
Why did a cheap team beat costly contractors?
Gebbia says his team first interviewed recent retirees about what they needed.
[24] Talk to retireesBuild for themOnline in six months
How it works
Designers call this user research: studying the people a system serves before building it.
Gebbia's team did user research with people about to retire, then built the application in about six months.
[24] Seen it before
A teacher who asks the class what confuses them writes a clearer worksheet.
The truth
- The $100 million and 20 years are Gebbia's own account, given on stage at a Fortune forum.
[24]
Good news
- Paper processing has ended for more than 95% of federal retirement applications, the agency says.
[24] - Federal retirement claims filed online took 59 days on average in October, against 150 days on paper.
-
US federal workers can now apply to retire online, after decades of paper forms.
-
08
Lenders check a new credit score, rarely use it
What happened
-
More than 170 US mortgage lenders now pull VantageScore 4.0, a newer credit score.
[25] -
But only about 8% of new loans in October were priced with it, Bank of America found.
[25] -
Most lenders still set loan prices with Classic FICO, the older score.
[25] -
Rocket Mortgage and UWM made 95% of the loans priced with the new score.
[25]
How it unfolded
Since October, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, which bundle mortgages for investors, require both scores shown when both are pulled.
[25] Why it matters
The pricing score helps set the terms a borrower gets, so the choice reaches every new borrower.
[25] Think it through
-
1
Can a lender pick whichever score is higher?
Yes: when both are present, lenders can choose.
[25] Loans priced with the new score scored about 43 points above FICO.[25] 43points higher on the new score, on loans priced with it
-
2
So why do most lenders still use FICO?
Bank of America thinks lenders' pricing systems are not yet ready for the new score.
[25] Pulling a score: easyPricing with it: hardMost stay on FICO
How it works
Statisticians call this a selection effect: pick the better of two measures, and the results you see run high.
In October 24% of loans had a FICO below 700 and 21% a new score below 700.
[25] Only 17% had a pricing score below 700.[25] Seen it before
A club that keeps your best of two jumps looks better than one that keeps your first.
The truth
- Bank of America offers the readiness reason as its analysts' view, not as the lenders' own explanation.
[25]
-
More than 170 US mortgage lenders now pull VantageScore 4.0, a newer credit score.
-
09
A UK benefits fault overpays a claimant
What happened
-
A known computer fault at the DWP, the UK benefits department, has overpaid one claimant's housing help for 18 months.
[26] -
She should get the shared-room rate of £586 a month, but has been paid £790.
[26] -
The overpayment is now more than £3,600, the Guardian worked out.
[26] -
Staff were told not to correct such claims by hand, the claimant learned.
[26]
How it unfolded
A tribunal ordered her allowance recalculated in April, but the system could not do it.
[26] - April tribunal orders a fix
- After system cannot do it
Why it matters
Her partner, an international student, may not receive public funds.
[26] So the overpayment could put his right to stay at risk.[26] Think it through
-
1
Why not just fix it?
The DWP blamed a recognised system defect.
[26] It then corrected her case by hand once the Guardian asked.[26] -
2
How many others does it hit?
The DWP says an extremely small number.
[26] It refused a request for the figure as too costly to collect.[26] -
3
So who carries the risk of the mistake?
The DWP made the error, but her partner carries the visa risk.
[26] The DWP says nobody will have to repay.[26]
How it works
UK immigration law calls this no recourse to public funds: a visa condition that bars most state benefits.
She gets the couple's rate because he lives with her, so he may count as benefiting from public funds.
[26] The Home Office could then cut his leave to remain.[26] Seen it before
A friend lends you a pass you are not allowed, and you, not the friend, get caught.
The truth
- The DWP says nobody will repay.
[26] But the Home Office decides visas, and it referred the question back to the DWP.[26]
-
A known computer fault at the DWP, the UK benefits department, has overpaid one claimant's housing help for 18 months.
-
10
US jobless expect worse than happens
What happened
-
New York Fed economists compared what US workers expect about jobs with what actually happens.
[27] -
Since 2022, 58.8% of newly unemployed people found work within three months.
[27] Workers expected only 53.0%.[27] -
The gap is widest for workers with a high school education or less: 7.5 points.
[27] -
After two years in a job, workers expect to lose it more than twice as often as they do.
[27]
Why it matters
The authors say such gloom may add to young people's downbeat view of the job market.
[27] Think it through
-
1
Who turned most gloomy?
Workers 30 or younger went from 6.3 points too hopeful before COVID to 3.0 points too gloomy.
[27] Points off the real rate
Before COVID6.3After3under-30s: too hopeful before, too gloomy after -
2
So why does fear of losing a job stay high?
Workers underrate how much safer a job gets the longer they keep it, the authors say.
[27] Longer in the jobReal risk falls fastFear falls slowly
How it works
Economists call these subjective expectations: what people believe their chances are, measured against what happens.
Before COVID, expected and real job-finding rates matched: 55.5% against 57.2%.
[27] After it, expectations stayed low while real rates recovered.[27] Seen it before
After one bad test, a pupil expects to fail the next, even when they are ready.
The truth
- The authors warn their job-loss measure misses people who quit just before a layoff, so it understates the real risk.
[27]
-
New York Fed economists compared what US workers expect about jobs with what actually happens.
-
11
Families buy one house with strangers
What happened
-
Two Vancouver families who had never met bought a six-bedroom house together in 2023, the BBC reports.
[29] -
It cost C$1.85 million, and the families split the C$250,000 deposit.
[29] -
They also split the C$3,900 monthly mortgage payment and the bills.
[29] -
Alone, their C$1 million budget would have bought a small flat with a balcony at best.
[29] -
In Toronto, an app called Husmates matches people who want to buy a home with a stranger.
[29]
Who is involved
- The Wilcoxes half the house
- The Pullmans half the house
Why it matters
Vancouver has long had some of Canada's highest house prices, which put a garden out of one family's reach.
[29] Think it through
-
1
What if one family wants out?
Both homes in the story have legal agreements with notice periods for anyone selling up.
[29] -
2
Why not just trust each other?
Toronto lawyer Tanya Walker says 'you need something legally binding', as emails and messages are too messy in a dispute.
[29] -
3
So who holds the power in a shared home?
In one Toronto home, a leaving owner must offer the others the first chance to buy their share.
[29] One owner leavesOthers offered the share firstThen outsiders
How it works
Property lawyers call this a right of first refusal: co-owners get first chance to buy a share being sold.
Sabrina Bowman's Toronto co-owners hold a right of first refusal on any share a departing owner sells.
[29] Seen it before
When a flatmate moves out, the others usually get first say on who takes the room.
The truth
- No official figures count people buying with strangers.
[29] A UK mortgage broker calls it very niche there.[29]
-
Two Vancouver families who had never met bought a six-bedroom house together in 2023, the BBC reports.
-
12
Strangers pool money to clear debts
What happened
-
A UK Facebook group, the Ripple Effect Project, raises money to pay off members' debts.
[28] -
It has grown to nearly 7,000 members since it started in September.
[28] -
Each week it picks one member at random, checks their debt privately, and opens a week-long fundraiser.
[28] -
One recent fundraiser raised £2,409 from 1,347 donations.
[28]
How it unfolded
Its founder copied a US group, Dollar by Dollar Relief, which has over 43,000 members.
[28] Why it matters
Online groups offer people in debt anonymity before they face a lender or adviser, StepChange, a debt charity, says.
[28] Think it through
-
1
Is a random pick a lottery?
No, says gambling lawyer Richard Williams: 'If it's free to participate it isn't regulated gambling.'
[28] -
2
What could go wrong?
StepChange worries people will wait to be picked instead of getting free debt advice.
[28] Hope to be pickedAdvice put offDebt grows -
3
So who decides who gets helped?
Chance does, and as the group grows each member's odds of being picked fall.
[28]
How it works
Economists call a pardner a rotating savings group: members pay in and take turns receiving the pot.
StepChange compares the Ripple Effect to the Caribbean pardner.
[28] Unlike a pardner, strangers give freely and one member is picked at random.[28] Seen it before
Friends each chip in a pound so one of them gets a big birthday present.
The truth
- About half of StepChange's clients wait a year or more before getting debt advice, its surveys find.
[28]
Good news
- The recipient, a new mother with no maternity pay, says the money relieved a lot of stress.
[28]
-
A UK Facebook group, the Ripple Effect Project, raises money to pay off members' debts.
-
13
Bookmaker fined for luring 18-year-olds
What happened
-
A Northern Territory regulator fined Australian bookmaker Amused Group $83,250 over sign-ups at a sports club.
[30] -
A club official posted that BetDeluxe, the club's new sponsor, offered $300 to players who signed up.
[30] -
About 15 people opened accounts, more than 10 of them 18-year-old women.
[30] -
Texts showed a senior Amused employee pushing the official for more sign-ups.
[30] -
Amused has since collapsed, owing about $5 million to 54 creditors.
[30]
Why it matters
The regulator called the 18-year-olds' sign-ups a concern for responsible gambling.
[30] Think it through
-
1
Did anyone lose money?
No: the commission found none of those who signed up suffered a financial loss.
[30] -
2
Who looks after the customers now?
Another firm, Matchday, now runs the business and has taken on all client funds.
[30] Amused collapsesMatchday buys the businessClient money moves over -
3
So who polices online betting?
The NT Wagering Commission acts as Australia's main online gambling regulator.
[30] The NT government is giving it more power.[30]
How it works
Gambling regulators call this an inducement: a reward offered to get someone to open a betting account.
BetDeluxe's $300 sign-up offer was an inducement, and it drew in about a dozen 18-year-olds.
[30] Seen it before
A sweet shop that hands free sweets to pupils at the school gate.
The truth
- Amused said the club post was not intended.
[30] The regulator said its own checks should have caught it.[30]
-
A Northern Territory regulator fined Australian bookmaker Amused Group $83,250 over sign-ups at a sports club.
-
14
Germany's 'bratwurst tax' worries volunteers
What happened
-
From 1 January, German towns must charge VAT, a tax on sales, on things they sell as traders do.
[31] -
That could mean volunteer fire brigades paying VAT on bratwursts sold at village festivals.
[31] -
It applies when a brigade is part of the town, not an independent association.
[31] -
Food sold at snack bars has carried a reduced 7% rate since 1 January 2026.
[31] Sellers must keep detailed records and issue receipts.[31]
How it unfolded
The rule, section 2b of Germany's VAT Act, has been delayed again and again.
[31] - Now backlash grows
- 1 January the rules apply
Why it matters
The records and receipts would fall on volunteers running stalls at local events.
[31] Think it through
-
1
Will brigades find a way round it?
A satirical piece on the website Kommunal.de predicts brigades will set up separate associations to keep selling.
[31] Brigade sellsNew association runs the stallNo town sale -
2
Who is pushing back?
In Schleswig-Holstein's parliament, the CDU, Greens and FDP want the rules paused or more exemptions.
[31] -
3
So who decides if the sausage is taxed?
State finance ministers can step in: North Rhine-Westphalia's reportedly exempted fire brigade bratwurst sales by decree.
[31]
How it works
Tax lawyers call this competitive neutrality: a public body that sells like a business is taxed like one.
A brigade inside the town sells food like a snack bar, so section 2b would tax it like one.
[31] Seen it before
A school bake sale charging the same tax as the bakery down the road.
The truth
- Whether a stall owes anything turns on whether its brigade counts as part of the town.
[31]
What comes next
The rules apply from 1 January.
[31] Exemptions can still come first, as North Rhine-Westphalia's did.[31] -
From 1 January, German towns must charge VAT, a tax on sales, on things they sell as traders do.
More Money editions
Across the beats